StMU Research Scholars

Featuring Scholarly Research, Writing, and Media at St. Mary’s University

September 30, 2018

Trouble in Fantasyland: Walt Disney’s Cartoons in Combat

Families throughout the United States faced hard times during the late-1930s. People were still recovering from the effects of the Great Depression, unfulfilled promises from President Roosevelt’s New Deal, and unemployment.1 During these financially troubled times, two dreamers, brothers Roy and Walt Disney, were on a mission to continue to produce quality animation on a fixed budget. After Fantasia‘s disappointing initial grossing, Disney Animation Studios’ debt was edging toward $3 million, which led to Walt Disney cutting all of his animators’ salaries. Although Roy Disney believed that this would undermine everything the two had built, he realized the only alternative was to sell their films through a franchise or file for bankruptcy, and so he agreed to the arrangement, unaware of the wrath that would follow.2

Walt Disney and his brother Roy with Florida’s Governor W. Haydon Burns announcing future company plans in 1965 |Courtesy of Wikimedia Commons

Tensions rose as animators also noticed a change in Walt Disney’s attitude toward them. The once cheerful man who was full of magic soon lost that touch, becoming distant to the people around him. Walt began to take all the credit for the animations that were being produced, and his employees soon realized that their pay was much lower than Disney’s salary. His ‘in-betweeners’ and clean up men were making $20 at the most, while his animators, ranging from amateurs to professionals, made between $75 and $300 weekly. Walt brought home a salary five times what his highest paid animators were bringing home.3

These pay disparities led his beloved animators to walk out on the company. On May 28, 1941, employees were greeted by hundreds of their coworkers waving signs preventing them from entering the studio. Although the exact number of employees who went on strike differs between sources, it is estimated that roughly one-third of the 1200 employees went out that morning. For the first few days of the strike, employees exchanged jokes and banter. The animators held up picket signs with clever illustrations that depicted their true emotions. One that struck deep to the studio was a picture of Walt Disney’s face in a cartoon style with crossed eyes and the caption “I can’t see why they’re unhappy.”4 Walt refused to give in to the demands of his employees, because he did not feel that they needed the increase in pay. This firm stance left the strike to go on for five whole weeks, tearing apart the company’s unity. This tension led Walt to leave for South America to take some time away from work, while he let go almost half of his team. After a bank representative for the company stepped in to review the case, the studio was sustained in favor of the animators leading to the dispute being settled. Though a treacherous three and a half months had passed, work finally resumed at the studio in Burbank, California with 694 employees on September 16, 1941.5

The poster for Walt Disney’s “Der Fuehrer’s Face”, a comical cartoon ridiculing Adolf Hitler starring Donald Duck, located in the Walt Disney Family Museum |Courtesy of Flickr

Just as everything seemed to be falling into place, the unimaginable happened. On December 7, 1941, the Japanese Navy Air service struck down on the United States naval base in Pearl Harbor sending the United States into World War II. Panic set in for the animators again as the cost of the films being produced during this time put a damper on the company’s overall budget.6 During this time, Walt and his company were sought out to produce cartoons for the armed services as morale builders. They also used half of the animation studio to house antiaircraft troops that were fighting during World War II. Although the company seemed to be taking on too much, this engagement would inspire Walt to create a few propaganda short films and war posters of his own that would speak to the people of the United States. Of all of the animation produced during the war, the most notable piece was Der Fuehrer’s Face, an animated short film in which Donald Duck dreams he is working in a German factory, all while ridiculing Adolf Hitler. The combination of housing troops in the studio, producing short films that expressed the idea of America’s freedom, and the efforts to inspire those fighting for the United States broaden the brand as a whole, showing every single American know what the Disney company stood for at the time.7

Though Walt himself did not find very creative success regarding his work toward the government propaganda animation and posters, it paid off very well for the company, raising its reputation and generating profits. The animation studio’s contributions to America during the World War II brought smiles with their comedic satire to families struggling to find hope as their loved were out serving their country. Soon after, they produced notable works such as Bambi (1942), Song of the South (1946), and Cinderella (1950), with Cinderella generating enough gross profit to pull the company out of debt and further establish their brand. Had both the strike and Walt lending a hand during the war not happened to the Walt Disney Animation Studios, Walt and Roy Disney may not have been able to sufficiently pay their ‘on the edge of leaving the company’ employers and the bills that came with owning the animation studio. The studio itself could have shut down permanently, never transforming from two passionate brothers’ project to a multi-billion dollar brand that brings magic fans and families all across the globe.

 

  1.  The Hutchinson Unabridged Encyclopedia with Atlas and Weather Guide, 2018, s.v. “The USA in the 1930s.”
  2. Neal Gabler, Walt Disney: The Triumph of the American Imagination (New York: Knopf, 2006), 350-351.
  3. Neal Gabler, Walt Disney: The Triumph of the American Imagination (New York: Knopf, 2006), 355.
  4. Steven Watts, The Magic Kingdom: Walt Disney and the American Way of Life (Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1997), 209
  5. Neal Gabler, Walt Disney: The Triumph of the American Imagination (New York: Knopf, 2006), 367-371
  6. Barry Keith Grant, “Walt Disney Company,” Schirmer Encyclopedia of Film, Vol. 4, (New York: Schirmer Reference, 2007), 331-336.
  7. Paul Lagasse, “Walt Disney,” The Columbia Encyclopedia, 8th ed. (Columbia: Columbia University Press, 2018)

Tags from the story

Depression

Disney

entertainment

film

propaganda

Roy Disney

Walt Disney

Recent Comments

Isabella Torres

I had no idea that there was so much controversy associated with Walt Disney since I have never really looked into it. It is crazy to think that if the strike as well as Walt’s action’s during World War II didn’t occur, then Disney would not be nearly as significant in American culture as it is today. I always had such a positive image for Walt Disney simply because of the memories I have of watching his films, but although my perspective of him has changed slightly after reading this article, my love for the movies is still the same.

reply

24/09/2019

9:19 pm

Bianca Villarreal

First of all, I didn’t even know there was another Disney brother; I only knew about Walt. Also, whenever I would hear the name Disney, I always thought of something positive. I never knew that he treated his workers so poorly. But it’s not a surprise seeing people become blinded by money and then after seeing that he basically went of vacation to get away from it is ridiculous. This article also makes me think about, what would’ve happened to Disney if the war never happened considering the rise of the company during WWII propaganda.

reply

27/09/2019

9:19 pm

Addie Piatz

I had heard a brief story about this specific topic and it made me think but it really did not change my opinion about Disney. Everyone has struggles to get where need to go. I love how cartoons and comics were really big during the world wars and even though the wars weren’t a positive thing, without them we would not have the Disney that we have today.

reply

29/09/2019

9:19 pm

Thalia Romo

Having grown up with Disney as one of the biggest company’s in the world, it’s challenging to hear of the terrible actions that were happening behind closed doors, especially since I love Disney films. The movie industry is something that will be a blur for me, but this article does a good job at shedding some light to one of the most well known names in media history.

reply

12/10/2019

9:19 pm

Cassandra Sanchez

It is really interesting to learn about how this company that provided for most of my childhood with their great films has actually faced problems and hardships that once divided themselves. I never knew that Disney refused to give his workers the right payment amounts and was taking credit for all his workers’ hard work. This seemingly perfect company has it’s own dark side which I think is shocking.

reply

12/10/2019

9:19 pm

Cynthia Perez

I wonder if there’s ever been a business that could honestly say they never faced any kind of difficulties or hardship in order to develop into something great. It’s understandable learning that Walt Disney had it’s rough upbringing and harsh moments in their company with the conflicts they faced with their employees. Of course at a time like that it would be difficult to please everybody. Thankfully they pulled through and persevered in order to establish this growing influential business across the world.

reply

13/10/2019

9:19 pm

Mara Martinez

Disney has always had a special place in my heart since I was a kid and even now. I love disney and everything it has to offer, this article was interesting to me how even way back when Disney was used to bring a huge smile on peoples faces, even when there really was no outlook on positivity. Which now it still has that effect on people, when they are down, it brings happiness.

reply

13/10/2019

9:19 pm

Amanda Uribe

I never knew any background on Disney animations until this. I am surprised that Walt did nothing about the employees protesting for weeks. I also wonder why Walt paid himself so much even though the company was doing bad. I am glad that they pulled through it because Disney has always made great movies that have a special spot in my heart.

reply

26/10/2019

9:19 pm

Victoria Davis

Disney is known to be the most magical place on earth and somewhere I personally really enjoyed myself at. I felt like a kid again enjoying all the rides and animation that was brought to life. This article really shows that even Disney went through a rough patch but was able to bring itself back. You never really hear about the hardships Disney faced until reading this article.

reply

28/10/2019

9:19 pm

Sebastian Azcui

Disney is one of the best things in the world. Disney basically marked my childhood. Disney was always made to entertain people and make people smile. But, I had no idea that Disney employees were on a strike and protested for weeks. Walt was able to pay everything and make the company stable again luckily.

reply

31/10/2019

9:19 pm

1 2 3 4 5

Leave a Reply