StMU Research Scholars

Featuring Scholarly Research, Writing, and Media at St. Mary’s University

November 4, 2018

China’s Plan to Shanghai Tibet

Imagine at the age of twenty-three having to walk at night across the Himalayan mountains, to survive and avoid imprisonment, torture, and certain death. This is the only choice the 14th Dalai Lama, Tenzin Gyatso, could make to avoid being imprisoned and most likely killed by the Chinese military.1 This set him on a perilous journey that required him to travel by night, dressed as a soldier, for two weeks and across the tallest and most lethal mountain range, the Himalayas. 2 This was his only option because the fate of his people and their ancient culture depended on his survival.3

Tibet as recognized by China Courtesy of Google Images

Tibet is nestled between the Southwestern border of China, and the Northeastern border of Nepal. Prior to China’s invasion of Tibet in 1950, Tibetan society was governed by a caste system centered around the Buddhist principle of reincarnation, the religion for a country ran as a Theocracy.4 Buddhist reincarnation suggests that if an individual lived a virtuous life, following his or her death, he or she reincarnates into the next highest caste and enjoys said caste’s privileges as the reward of a deeply humble and virtuous life. The one who served as a symbol of unity for the people and who ruled the country by maintaining Tibetan traditions in combining the duties of the spiritual leader and political leader of Tibet is the Dalai Lama.5 The Dalai Lama is not representative of any one school of Buddhist thought, instead he advocates traditional Buddhist values and the preservation of Tibetan traditions.

Tenzin Gyatso the 14th Dalai Lama Courtesy of Wikipedia Commons

During the near two-hundred-year rule of China’s Qing Dynasty (1720- 1912), the Dalai Lama was the head of Tibet’s government, with the government enjoying almost complete sovereignty at times. Following the collapse of the Qing Dynasty, in 1914 a convention was held in which British India, China, and Tibet agreed to make Tibet semi-autonomous. 6 Under the agreement China, which never had full control over Tibet, handled Tibet’s foreign relations while Tibet handled its internal affairs and maintained an army. However, thirty-five years later, the plan to rob Tibetans of their autonomy and rights was set in motion.

In 1949, Mao Zedong established China as a communist state known as the People’s Republic of China. A mere two months later Mao ordered the “liberation” of Tibet from its Buddhist leaders.7 The Chinese government painted the Dalai Lama as the architect of a regressive and feudal regime, and promoted themselves as a heroic force of change. 8 Mao believed that Tibet only enjoyed autonomy due to the machinations of foreign influences. He cited Chinese traditions that claimed Tibetans were one of the five races that made up China as evidence that Tibet’s rightful place was as a province of China.9 In 1950, the Chinese military invaded Tibet and defeated its army. Instead of occupying the country, the Chinese government invited Tibetan officials to negotiate an agreement between the two. At the meeting, the Tibetan representatives signed a Seventeen-Point Agreement, acknowledging China’s sovereignty over Tibet.10 The Tibetan government refuted this agreement’s legitimacy, claiming that the delegation sent was not authorized to sign any such documents, nor were they allowed to communicate back home the nature of their situation. It was this combination of Tibet’s military defeat and forced signing of the agreement that set the stage for Mao’s occupation of Tibet and the erosion of Tibet’s freedom and rights.

In 1951, China began exerting its newly affirmed control over Tibet by sending troops into the country and implementing communist reforms. The first reform implemented was the settling Tibetans who were typically a nomadic people and the settlement of more Chinese citizens to the region. The second reform instituted was land redistribution, crops were confiscated by the Chinese government and given to a central authority with only a small amount returned to Tibetans. However, land redistribution was not implemented uniformly across Tibet, reforms were inexplicably delayed in western Tibet, and society largely continued unchanged. Eastern Tibet on the other hand rebelled in 1956, with monasteries and noblemen leading the resistance against Chinese Communists. Guerilla fighters were successful in capturing control of Southern Tibet, however this uprising was costly. The Tibetan uprising of 1959 alone costing anywhere from 85,000 to 87,000 lives, and the response by China resulted in 10,000 to 15,000 Tibetans dying over the course of three days. Fearing the capture of the Dalai Lama, Tibetan citizens surrounded his residence in an effort to protect him.11 Tibetans chose to stand against the Chinese troops outraged by the previous nine years of egregious human rights violations that included many soldiers raping and murdering Buddhist nuns and monks who resisted the reforms.

With this opportunity to escape provided to him by his people the Dalai Lama began is harrowing thirteen-day trek on foot through the Himalayas to India. Upon arriving in India, representatives sent by Prime Minister Nehru welcomed him and the refugees that had followed hoping to escape the atrocities currently being inflicted upon their homeland. The Dalai Lama worked alongside his people who fled to establish the Tibetan government in exile in Dharamshala, Himachal Pradesh, India.

Dharamshala, Himachal Pradesh, India, home of the Tibetan government in exile. Courtesy of Wikipedia Commons

During his time as both the head of the exiled government and after having stepped down from said position the Dalai Lama has worked furiously advocating not just the rights of Tibetans, but people all across the globe.12 The Dalai Lama has spoken on a variety of social issues ranging from the environment, to economics, reproductive health, sexuality, interfaith dialogue, women’s rights, and nonviolence. “Furthermore, everyone appreciates affection and at the same time has the potential for showing affection to others. With this in mind, I have found that friendship and understanding can develop.”13 All while being unable to return to his home of Tibet and not knowing how his subsequent reincarnation was to be found. His existence challenges the Chinese government’s blatant disregard for human rights, which include massacres, tortures, killings, bombardment of monasteries, extermination of nomad camps, and violating at least sixteen articles of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Now 81 years old, he may be the last Dalai Lama. The Dalai Lama is traditionally found following his reincarnation by the Panchen Lama, someone who is akin to our U.S. Vice President. Along with the numerous human rights violations committed the Chinese government also arrested both the Panchen Lama and his family, then named their own Panchen Lama in 1995, thereby creating uncertainty as to whether the next reincarnation would follow Tibet’s traditions or serve the Chinese government’s interests.14 To dispel this fog of doubt and concern, the Dalai Lama announced a plan to determine the future of his reincarnation, upon him turning ninety, the Dalai Lama will convene with a trust to decide if it is necessary for a 15th Dalai Lama to be recognized. If it is determined that his reincarnation is necessary, then the Gaden Phodrang Trust will search for and recognize the 15th Dalai Lama, along with the caveat that any person chosen by the Chinese government is to be dismissed by all people.15

Despite attacks on his home, his religion, and himself, the Dalai Lama persists in refusing to call for violence against China. For over fifty years this man, now in the twilight of his life, has spread his message of peace and understanding to the world hoping he could help country and his people one day see the restoration of their basic human rights following years of blatant abuse and maltreatment.16

  1.  Charles George and Linda George, The Dalai Lama, (People in the News. Detroit: Lucent Books, 2010), 50-51.
  2. Latson Jennifer, How and Why the Dalai Lama Left Tibet, www.time.com.
  3.  Charles George and Linda George, The Dalai Lama, (People in the News. Detroit: Lucent Books, 2010), 37.
  4. Charles Bell, Tibet and Its Neighbors, (Vancouver: Pacific Affairs, University of British Columbia, 1937), 428-440.
  5. Robert Thurman, Why The Dalai Lama matters, (New York: Atria Books, 2008), 3.
  6.  Jennifer Stock, Global Events: Milestone Events Throughout History: Vol 2: Asia and Oceania, (Farmington Hills: Gale, 2014), 373-376.
  7. Charles Henry Alexandrowicz-Alexander, The American Journal of International Law: Vol. 48: No. 2(Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1954), 265-274.
  8.  Charles George and Linda George, The Dalai Lama, (People in the News. Detroit: Lucent Books, 2010), 9.
  9. Elliot Sperling, Tibet and China: The Interpretation of History Since 1950: China Perspective Vol 3, (2009), 25-26.
  10. Alex McKay, The History of Tibet: Vol 3 The Modern Period: 1859- 1959, (London and New York: Routledge Curzon, 2003), 607-609.
  11.  Charles George and Linda George, The Dalai Lama, (People in the News. Detroit: Lucent Books, 2010), 47-48.
  12. His Holiness The Dalai Lama and Howard C. Cutler, The Art of Happiness,(New York: Riverhead Books, 1998), 2.
  13.  Charles George and Linda George, The Dalai Lama, (People in the News. Detroit: Lucent Books, 2010), 64.
  14. Eric A. McGuckin, Tibet: Struggle for Independence.” In History Behind the Headlines: The Origins of Conflicts Worldwide, (Farmington Hills: Gale, 2003), 272.
  15. The Dalai Lama, Reincarnation, (Dharamsala: The Dalai Lama, 2011).
  16.  Gary L. Anderson and Kathryn G. Herr, Encyclopedia of Activism and Social Justice, Vol. 3, (Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications Inc, 2007), 417-418.

Tags from the story

1959

Autonomy

Buddhism

China

His Holiness the 14th Dalai Lama

Human Rights Violations

Panchen Lama

Recent Comments

Max Lerma

Great article! I think it is incredible that this man has not allowed the persecution and the resentment of towards his religion by the Chinese government to sway how he worships or his outlook upon life. That takes a remarkable amount of strength and resilience that not many possess. His story is undoubtedly fraught with peril, but is an inspirational one as well. Thank you for this article, and for making sure the reader stays engaged and interested for the entirety of the piece.

reply

05/11/2018

11:49 pm

Robert Freise

This article is very intriguing. The things that Dalia Lama is a very influential. The push for pea cer and harmony within societies is beautiful to me in my eyes. The people that he represented are very deserving in having their freedom just like the Chinese people. The rationals that the Tibetan people express is very captivating by how peaceful they are and how they can be so timid and orchestrate things. Great article!!

reply

05/11/2018

11:49 pm

Matthew Wyatt

A great article about one of the world’s greatest minds. The Dalai Lama’s story of maintaining a belief in peace and tranquility in the face of abject persecution is nothing short of inspiring. A few edits will make this peace even more powerful and moving. For example, a few sentences appear to be run-ons, and could easily be broken into two or more sentences. Making these changes will help to better share the story of this brave man and his message of prevailing humanity in spite of brutal inhumanity.

reply

05/11/2018

11:49 pm

Andrea Cabrera

The introduction into this article was excellent. The way it was written made you travel in time and space to understand the point of view of the person this article is about. The Republic of China has had different changes throughout history. Dynasties are a key point of how China social system used to work. Now, as a communist country some aspects have changed due to modernization. This was a very informative and concise article! Good job!

reply

05/11/2018

11:49 pm

Robert Ruiz

Hey Rob, nice article. I honestly did not know much about The Dalai Lama, but after reading your article he kind of reminded me of people like Martin Luther King Jr., Mother Teresa, and many other non-violent activists. What is amazing for him, is witnessing so many human rights violations over his lifetime and not wanting to fight back. I thought your images were nice as well, and worked with what I was reading. Overall, I enjoyed reading your article.

reply

07/11/2018

11:49 pm

Mariana Valadez

This article was extremely well written and beyond interesting. I have always loved to read quotes from the Dalai Lama and believe it is a good mindset to follow. He is super inspiring, and I could not ever imagine anyone being against him. His approach with peace is a way everyone should try to aspire to use. This was a great article!

reply

08/11/2018

11:49 pm

Harashang Gajjar

It was a defiant gesture, like that of the nomad who had watched from outside his tent as the train went past. And when I returned to Lhasa later that morning the city, overwhelmingly defined by the Chinese, appeared more clearly to be an exception. It seemed that there were many more Tibetans like the young farmer, asserting traditional ways of life against change imposed from Beijing—Tibetans whose loyalty to their faith and identity had been tested by successive political setbacks, and who would now struggle to survive the arrival of the railroad in Lhasa.

reply

08/11/2018

11:49 pm

Micaela Cruz

Prior to reading this article, I did not have much insight on the Dalai Lama and the such adversity they may face, specifically in this situation. It was interesting to learn about the current situation surrounding the 14th Dalai Lama and what all he’s endured to protect himself along with his followers in order to avoid the harsh rule of the Chinese. An overall good read.

reply

09/11/2018

11:49 pm

Greyson Addicott

Mao Zedong is a very influential and unique character to study, especially when one considers his leadership over Maoist China. Every war that Mao waged in the East was considered a “liberation” rather than an “armed conflict,” and this article explained that very well. Mao refused to recognize the sovereignty of Tibet, and I am sure that he would be very surprised that his invasion was eventually all for naught. Regardless, a Maoist China would today dominate the world press, and would be much more interesting to read about than the current state of Neo-Leninist China.

reply

09/11/2018

11:49 pm

Luis Magana

I had no idea what this article was going to talk about when I initially read the title. Surprisingly it was very interesting. Dalia Lama was such a courageous, brave and special person. He cared for so many and didn’t wanna allow for any more persecutions. I can’t believe the Tibetan were so peaceful while they were having to endure so much I would know how I would react in a situation like that. There should be more people in this world like that with a purpose.

reply

09/11/2018

11:49 pm

1 2 3

Leave a Reply