StMU Research Scholars

Featuring Scholarly Research, Writing, and Media at St. Mary's University
April 7, 2019

Breaking Silence or Just Speaking Louder?: The Story of Larry Nassar and his 499 Victims

The phone rings and when you answer the call, a person claiming to be with law enforcement tells you that he or she has discovered some naked pictures of you when you were a child on your trainer’s computer. Trinea Gonzcar recalls this exact event as the turning point in the way she saw one of her mentors.

“We can’t tell you if it’s you, but there were images of little girls in his bathtub,” said the official.1

Larry Nassar had been in Gonzcar’s life for over thirty-one years, and Gonzcar was a huge advocate of him and his treatment. She could not believe that the one person who she looked up to, who healed her from all of her injuries, and who was there to listen to her when she needed him, hurt her in an unimaginable way.2

The United States is known for having a culture that absolutely loves sports. From the World Series to March Madness and the Super Bowl, the United States has always made sports a huge spectacle. The Olympic Games are no different, as they are an opportunity for many athletes to represent their country in the sport they love the most. Among many other sports, competing in gymnastics is the dream of many little girls who want to showcase their skills on a stage this huge. Gonzcar, a little girl with colossal dreams, was among these special ladies seeking the opportunity. At the age of six she joined the gym Twistars and knew that gymnastics would be her new passion. In a family of five, Gonzcar was the most intense and competitive. Twistars soon became her second home as she spent most of her time training in the gym when she was not at school.3

Gonzcar proved to have strong potential at a young age and began to train with Larry Nassar at the age of nine, when she was selected to be on the team of John Geddert, the owner of Twistars gym. Gonzcar’s mother, Dawn Homer, recalled one of the coaches speaking out in a parent meeting about injuries, stating that, “One hundred percent of the girls would be injured but we have a trainer right here.” The coach was referring to Larry Nassar.4

Nassar was a graduate of the University of Michigan, and he began working for the USA Olympics in 1986 as an athletic trainer and later as a physician. Nassar was a well-known individual with medical degrees in kinesiology and osteopathic medicine. He worked his way up from being a high school trainer to a trainer at his alma mater before earning a spot in the big leagues as a national medical coordinator for United States of America Gymnastics (USAG). In other words, this man’s track record was squeaky clean and all those with whom he interacted loved him.5

Larry Nassar, right bottom corner, helping Olympic gymnast Kerri Strug, at the 1996 Olympics. |IOPP/AFP/Getty Images

Gonzcar was no different from anyone else. She loved spending time with Nassar because she knew that he was the best at what he did and would always heal her injuries quickly, which meant more training and a better opportunity for competition.

“We called it magic of Larry–he could fix you so you could compete. And I wanted to compete,” Gonzcar said.6

All of the girls that attended Twistars gym were truly scared of Geddert because of how cruel and strict his training could be. So Nassar became their escape. They completely and utterly trusted Nassar because he was encouraging and made sure that the girls knew their potential. In 1990, when Gonzcar was nine years old, she noticed that her hip began to pop out of its socket whenever she was on bars, an injury for which she would go to Nassar for treatment. Nassar decided that she was in need of more treatment than what he could provide her at the gym, so he asked to meet Gonzcar and her mother at his apartment. This was an honor for Gonzcar, who took a lot of pride in the invitation, and her relationship with Nassar began to grow.7

When she arrived at Nassar’s home, there was already an ice bath set up in his bathtub with a magazine and a 14-minute timer. After this bath, Gonzcar got dressed and followed him to his treatment table, where her mom was seated in a position where she was only able to see Gonzcar’s head and shoulders. Nassar made Gonzcar lay on her stomach and put one of her legs across her hip while having a conversation with her mother. Meanwhile, he penetrated Gonzcar with an ungloved hand. This same incident happened over 856 times, according to Gonzcar’s attorney.8

Trinea Gonzcar in younger days. | Courtesy of Trinea Gonzcar

Sexual abuse can be defined as an individual forcing unwanted sexual contact or behavior onto another. There are many experts who believe that sexual abuse is the most under-reported type of child mistreatment, which usually occurs because children are most likely to be abused by those they trust or those who have some type of power over them.9 According to the NIS-1 data provided by the Children’s Bureau, 83% of sexual abuse victims are girls. In these same statistics, 32% are 15-17 years old, 28% range from 12-14 years old, and 21% are from 9-11 years old. Unfortunately, these types of situations are increasingly recognized as a cause, or moreover the trigger, for mental health problems.10

Unfortunately, Gonzcar was not the only one who experienced sexual abuse from Nassar. In the late 90’s another gymnast Gonzcar was acquainted with shared the same experience as her. The girl expressed that Nassar would penetrate her with his fingers, and Gonzcar began to realize that the same thing was happening to many of the other gymnasts. She was not alone, but she quickly expressed that Nassar’s treatment was normal, and that it was how they were going to get better. Nassar was Gonzcar’s hero and no one understood him like she did, so she would defend him until his name was cleared. If she could only talk to those girls who made those accusations, she could make them understand that it was not what they thought.11

Over the course of more than twenty years, there were multiple accusations against Nassar made to MSU and to other coaches at the Twistars gym, accusations that never made it to the police. No action was taken, as those who were in the position of confronting and possibly firing him believed that Nassar was a great man incapable of such morbid actions. Many reports were made, yet no voices were heard.

It was not until 2014, when gymnast Amanda Thomashow accused Nassar of assaulting her when she went in for a hip injury at MSU, that a problem was raised. Although the directors at MSU cleared Nassar of any possible wrongdoing, the incident got the attention of many other young girls who were experiencing the same thing. Similarly, it was a hip injury that landed Gonzcar in Larry’s arms over twenty years prior. Gonzcar’s opinion on Nassar did not reach its ultimate potential until she received that particular phone call about the investigation. Moreover, Nassar did plead guilty to sexual abuse of some of the girls in 2017.12 It all began to make sense, how even when Gonzcar went in for treatment for her wrists and ankles, she was somehow still getting her back and hip treatment–but she had always believed that he was fixing her and never suspected otherwise.13

Finally, after a rigorous investigation conducted by Detective Lieutenant Andrea Muford, Nassar was arrested. On May 12, 2017, he had to face about 200 of his victims in trial while each of them told their story in court. Among the many testimonies was that of Gonzcar, who referred to him directly when speaking.14 The pain in her voice grabbed the attention of everyone in the room. She was facing the man that, until a couple of months before, she had admired so dearly and defended. Now she felt offended that he betrayed her and her family and that he had committed such repulsive crimes over the course of three decades to hundreds of women.15

Victim Emily Ann Miller and mother, Leslie Miller, testifying against Nassar in trial. | Courtesy of Brendan Mcdermid/ Reuters

Nassar lost absolutely everything when he was sentenced to life in prison. Nassar’s wife divorced him, his medical license was revoked, and his name was tarnished. The squeaky clean reputation that he had maintained and that had kept him out of trouble for so long was no longer around. The USA Olympics and Michigan State University both issued statements apologizing to the girls who were mistreated by Nassar, and both parties are dealing with some lawsuits of their own. At the end of the day, justice was served and although the trauma that the girls have had to deal with will still be around for years to come, at least their abuser can no longer do any harm to them or any more innocent girls.

  1. Kerry Howley, “Everyone Believed Larry Nassar,” New York Magazine 51, no. 23 (2018): 24.
  2. Kerry Howley, “Everyone Believed Larry Nassar,” New York Magazine 51, no. 23 (2018): 23.
  3. Kerry Howley, “Everyone Believed Larry Nassar,” New York Magazine 51, no. 23 (2018): 23.
  4. Kerry Howley, “Everyone Believed Larry Nassar,” New York Magazine 51, no. 23 (2018): 23.
  5. Matt Mencarini, “Inside the investigation and prosecution of Larry Nassar,” Lansing State Journal (2018).
  6. “Day 4 of Larry Nassar Sentencing,” YouTube video, 8:43, posted by ” Alexandra Ilitch,” January 20, 2018,
  7. Kerry Howley, “Everyone Believed Larry Nassar,” New York Magazine 51, no. 23 (2018): 25.
  8. Kerry Howley, “Everyone Believed Larry Nassar,” New York Magazine 51, no. 23 (2018): 26.
  9. Kristen Key and Rebecca J. Frey, “Sexual Abuse,” The Gale Encyclopedia of Mental Health, 3rded. (Detroit, M.I.: Gale, 2012), 1391.
  10. Heather Cecil, “Childhood Sexual Abuse,” in Encyclopedia of Sociology, 2nded. (New York, NY.: Macmilan Reference USA, 2001), 289.
  11. Kerry Howley, “Everyone Believed Larry Nassar,” New YorkMagazine 51, no. 23 (2018): 27.
  12. Matt Mencarini, “Inside the investigation and prosecution of Larry Nassar,” Lansing State Journal (2018).
  13. “Day 4 of Larry Nassar Sentencing,” YouTube video, 8:43, posted by ” Alexandra Ilitch,” January 20, 2018,
  14. Matt Mencarini, “Inside the investigation and prosecution of Larry Nassar,” Lansing State Journal (2018).
  15. “Day 4 of Larry Nassar Sentencing,” YouTube video, 14:50, posted by ” Alexandra Ilitch,” January 20, 2018,

Paola Arellano

Author Portfolio Page

Recent Comments


  • Kayla Braxton-Young

    After reading this article I have become more informed about sexual abuse in a sports context. I really enjoyed reading the article. This article really caught my attention because of the title of this article. This title made me think that the topic and this article would be interesting to read, and it really was interesting to read. Nassar was a very important and big named trainer who trained a bunch of athletes, not to mention he affected at least 500 athletes. Sometimes you just think to yourself, just why? But you seem to never find the answer to that question, some people just have different minds and think differently. Trainers are people that athletes trust, and how do we trust someone when they assault you or assault people you may know? This is a great article.

  • Madeline Bloom

    This article was shocking. I knew about Larry Nassar before reading this but I never realized it was almost 500 athletes that he effected. Sexual abuse from athletic trainers happens more then you think. I’m not saying it is common but it happens to athletes everywhere, but the athlete does not know better. Athletes are trusting these trainers that what they are doing is bettering their bodies so that they do not hurt themselves more.

  • Aaron Sandoval

    This article was at times difficult to read, but it was informative and necessary nonetheless. I had never heard of Nassar or his actions, but the author did a good job of informing the reader of his crimes, and the lives of those who trusted him that will never be the same. Unlike many stories that cover this topic, I am glad that justice was served.

  • Vivian Urrutia

    Larry Nassar is a disgusting guy for taking the childhood and innocency of so many children, including little girls, teenage girls and even some boys. It knew about him before because I have heard the story from Simone Biles point of view but I would have never imagine this level of cruelty exists, he abused 499 victims. Reading this broke my heart because it is so hard to read that so many girls were either afraid to speak up or so innocent to even know what Nassar’s intentions were. Nevertheless, Detective Lieutenant Andrea Muford did a great job in uncovering all of the victims for him to pay in jail. It is sad for young women athletes because this is still a problem going on in the Sport world.

  • Nadia Manitzas

    After reading this article I got a very uneasy feeling when I thought of Nassar’s name. The fact that these women were unaware that they were being sexually abused is so heartbreaking. They only wanted to compete in the sport they loved and Nassar ruined it for them not just physically but emotionally and mentally. He deserves everything that he got and all the women who testified against him should feel some peace to know that their abuser is locked up. You do the crime, you serve the time. I hope that this never happens again to the USA Olympic Gymnastics team and their young athletes.

  • Hali Garcia

    I remember hearing Nassar’s name on the news years ago when the accusations were coming up. His accusations made me more aware of what women face and taught me to pay more attention. This article was very informative of who he is and how he betrayed these young women who trusted him and whom he was supposed to help. It is absolutely sickening what he did to them and I am glad that he lost everything but I am still curious of what the rest of his sentencing was because I do not remember.

  • Melanie Fraire

    This story was very difficult to get through since these girls were so innocent and unaware of what was being done to them, it’s pretty disgusting how he got away with so much. However, it’s stories like these that I hope bring more attention to the sexual abuse girls go through and even remain quiet about out of fear, for these girls I’m sure they were afraid to ruin someone’s “squeaky clean” reputation.

  • Savannah Alcazar

    I did not know about Nassar prior to this article. I can’t believe he got away with penetrating young girls with hip injuries for so long! I think that it is the parents responsibility to make their children aware of things that are and are NOT ok when it comes to physical contact. The parents need to make their children comfortable talking about these topics and inform them of what is classified as abuse. Things like this make me thankful my mom was overprotective throughout my childhood and athletic career. However, it is the 110% offenders fault in every case… it is important for parents to protect and educate their children because there are evil people in this world.

  • Carlos Apodaca

    I heard about Nassar and the terrible things he did but I never really learned about what went down and this article did a great job in showing the ocurance of the events that unfolded. Its sickening how this man was able to do this to the women that were supposed to trust him. Im glad justice was served and even though these events cant be undone I hope the Olympic team is able to never repeat this mistake ever again.

  • Juliana Montoya

    Nassar was a very big name on the news a couple of years back because of the sexual abuse accusations. It is very upsetting to read about how he betrayed so many young women who looked up to him and how a lot of them trusted him. The story about Gonzcar and the betrayal she felt from him was very eye opening on the fact that it is very hard to trust people.

Leave your comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.