StMU Research Scholars

Featuring Scholarly Research, Writing, and Media at St. Mary’s University

April 7, 2019

Breaking Silence or Just Speaking Louder?: The Story of Larry Nassar and his 499 Victims

The phone rings and when you answer the call, a person claiming to be with law enforcement tells you that he or she has discovered some naked pictures of you when you were a child on your trainer’s computer. Trinea Gonzcar recalls this exact event as the turning point in the way she saw one of her mentors.

“We can’t tell you if it’s you, but there were images of little girls in his bathtub,” said the official.1

Larry Nassar had been in Gonzcar’s life for over thirty-one years, and Gonzcar was a huge advocate of him and his treatment. She could not believe that the one person who she looked up to, who healed her from all of her injuries, and who was there to listen to her when she needed him, hurt her in an unimaginable way.2

The United States is known for having a culture that absolutely loves sports. From the World Series to March Madness and the Super Bowl, the United States has always made sports a huge spectacle. The Olympic Games are no different, as they are an opportunity for many athletes to represent their country in the sport they love the most. Among many other sports, competing in gymnastics is the dream of many little girls who want to showcase their skills on a stage this huge. Gonzcar, a little girl with colossal dreams, was among these special ladies seeking the opportunity. At the age of six she joined the gym Twistars and knew that gymnastics would be her new passion. In a family of five, Gonzcar was the most intense and competitive. Twistars soon became her second home as she spent most of her time training in the gym when she was not at school.3

Gonzcar proved to have strong potential at a young age and began to train with Larry Nassar at the age of nine, when she was selected to be on the team of John Geddert, the owner of Twistars gym. Gonzcar’s mother, Dawn Homer, recalled one of the coaches speaking out in a parent meeting about injuries, stating that, “One hundred percent of the girls would be injured but we have a trainer right here.” The coach was referring to Larry Nassar.4

Nassar was a graduate of the University of Michigan, and he began working for the USA Olympics in 1986 as an athletic trainer and later as a physician. Nassar was a well-known individual with medical degrees in kinesiology and osteopathic medicine. He worked his way up from being a high school trainer to a trainer at his alma mater before earning a spot in the big leagues as a national medical coordinator for United States of America Gymnastics (USAG). In other words, this man’s track record was squeaky clean and all those with whom he interacted loved him.5

Larry Nassar, right bottom corner, helping Olympic gymnast Kerri Strug, at the 1996 Olympics. |IOPP/AFP/Getty Images

Gonzcar was no different from anyone else. She loved spending time with Nassar because she knew that he was the best at what he did and would always heal her injuries quickly, which meant more training and a better opportunity for competition.

“We called it magic of Larry–he could fix you so you could compete. And I wanted to compete,” Gonzcar said.6

All of the girls that attended Twistars gym were truly scared of Geddert because of how cruel and strict his training could be. So Nassar became their escape. They completely and utterly trusted Nassar because he was encouraging and made sure that the girls knew their potential. In 1990, when Gonzcar was nine years old, she noticed that her hip began to pop out of its socket whenever she was on bars, an injury for which she would go to Nassar for treatment. Nassar decided that she was in need of more treatment than what he could provide her at the gym, so he asked to meet Gonzcar and her mother at his apartment. This was an honor for Gonzcar, who took a lot of pride in the invitation, and her relationship with Nassar began to grow.7

When she arrived at Nassar’s home, there was already an ice bath set up in his bathtub with a magazine and a 14-minute timer. After this bath, Gonzcar got dressed and followed him to his treatment table, where her mom was seated in a position where she was only able to see Gonzcar’s head and shoulders. Nassar made Gonzcar lay on her stomach and put one of her legs across her hip while having a conversation with her mother. Meanwhile, he penetrated Gonzcar with an ungloved hand. This same incident happened over 856 times, according to Gonzcar’s attorney.8

Trinea Gonzcar in younger days. | Courtesy of Trinea Gonzcar

Sexual abuse can be defined as an individual forcing unwanted sexual contact or behavior onto another. There are many experts who believe that sexual abuse is the most under-reported type of child mistreatment, which usually occurs because children are most likely to be abused by those they trust or those who have some type of power over them.9 According to the NIS-1 data provided by the Children’s Bureau, 83% of sexual abuse victims are girls. In these same statistics, 32% are 15-17 years old, 28% range from 12-14 years old, and 21% are from 9-11 years old. Unfortunately, these types of situations are increasingly recognized as a cause, or moreover the trigger, for mental health problems.10

Unfortunately, Gonzcar was not the only one who experienced sexual abuse from Nassar. In the late 90’s another gymnast Gonzcar was acquainted with shared the same experience as her. The girl expressed that Nassar would penetrate her with his fingers, and Gonzcar began to realize that the same thing was happening to many of the other gymnasts. She was not alone, but she quickly expressed that Nassar’s treatment was normal, and that it was how they were going to get better. Nassar was Gonzcar’s hero and no one understood him like she did, so she would defend him until his name was cleared. If she could only talk to those girls who made those accusations, she could make them understand that it was not what they thought.11

Over the course of more than twenty years, there were multiple accusations against Nassar made to MSU and to other coaches at the Twistars gym, accusations that never made it to the police. No action was taken, as those who were in the position of confronting and possibly firing him believed that Nassar was a great man incapable of such morbid actions. Many reports were made, yet no voices were heard.

It was not until 2014, when gymnast Amanda Thomashow accused Nassar of assaulting her when she went in for a hip injury at MSU, that a problem was raised. Although the directors at MSU cleared Nassar of any possible wrongdoing, the incident got the attention of many other young girls who were experiencing the same thing. Similarly, it was a hip injury that landed Gonzcar in Larry’s arms over twenty years prior. Gonzcar’s opinion on Nassar did not reach its ultimate potential until she received that particular phone call about the investigation. Moreover, Nassar did plead guilty to sexual abuse of some of the girls in 2017.12 It all began to make sense, how even when Gonzcar went in for treatment for her wrists and ankles, she was somehow still getting her back and hip treatment–but she had always believed that he was fixing her and never suspected otherwise.13

Finally, after a rigorous investigation conducted by Detective Lieutenant Andrea Muford, Nassar was arrested. On May 12, 2017, he had to face about 200 of his victims in trial while each of them told their story in court. Among the many testimonies was that of Gonzcar, who referred to him directly when speaking.14 The pain in her voice grabbed the attention of everyone in the room. She was facing the man that, until a couple of months before, she had admired so dearly and defended. Now she felt offended that he betrayed her and her family and that he had committed such repulsive crimes over the course of three decades to hundreds of women.15

Victim Emily Ann Miller and mother, Leslie Miller, testifying against Nassar in trial. | Courtesy of Brendan Mcdermid/ Reuters

Nassar lost absolutely everything when he was sentenced to life in prison. Nassar’s wife divorced him, his medical license was revoked, and his name was tarnished. The squeaky clean reputation that he had maintained and that had kept him out of trouble for so long was no longer around. The USA Olympics and Michigan State University both issued statements apologizing to the girls who were mistreated by Nassar, and both parties are dealing with some lawsuits of their own. At the end of the day, justice was served and although the trauma that the girls have had to deal with will still be around for years to come, at least their abuser can no longer do any harm to them or any more innocent girls.

  1. Kerry Howley, “Everyone Believed Larry Nassar,” New York Magazine 51, no. 23 (2018): 24.
  2. Kerry Howley, “Everyone Believed Larry Nassar,” New York Magazine 51, no. 23 (2018): 23.
  3. Kerry Howley, “Everyone Believed Larry Nassar,” New York Magazine 51, no. 23 (2018): 23.
  4. Kerry Howley, “Everyone Believed Larry Nassar,” New York Magazine 51, no. 23 (2018): 23.
  5. Matt Mencarini, “Inside the investigation and prosecution of Larry Nassar,” Lansing State Journal (2018).
  6. “Day 4 of Larry Nassar Sentencing,” YouTube video, 8:43, posted by ” Alexandra Ilitch,” January 20, 2018, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=63gVf1oUd4Q.
  7. Kerry Howley, “Everyone Believed Larry Nassar,” New York Magazine 51, no. 23 (2018): 25.
  8. Kerry Howley, “Everyone Believed Larry Nassar,” New York Magazine 51, no. 23 (2018): 26.
  9. Kristen Key and Rebecca J. Frey, “Sexual Abuse,” The Gale Encyclopedia of Mental Health, 3rded. (Detroit, M.I.: Gale, 2012), 1391.
  10. Heather Cecil, “Childhood Sexual Abuse,” in Encyclopedia of Sociology, 2nded. (New York, NY.: Macmilan Reference USA, 2001), 289.
  11. Kerry Howley, “Everyone Believed Larry Nassar,” New YorkMagazine 51, no. 23 (2018): 27.
  12. Matt Mencarini, “Inside the investigation and prosecution of Larry Nassar,” Lansing State Journal (2018).
  13. “Day 4 of Larry Nassar Sentencing,” YouTube video, 8:43, posted by ” Alexandra Ilitch,” January 20, 2018, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=63gVf1oUd4Q
  14. Matt Mencarini, “Inside the investigation and prosecution of Larry Nassar,” Lansing State Journal (2018).
  15. “Day 4 of Larry Nassar Sentencing,” YouTube video, 14:50, posted by ” Alexandra Ilitch,” January 20, 2018, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=63gVf1oUd4Q

Tags from the story

gymnastics

Larry Nassar

sexual abuse

Trinea Gonzcar

Recent Comments

Fatima Navarro

It’s so disturbing that Larry Nassar was able to get away with his disgusting acts towards these young women for so many years. It makes one wonder, how many of these cases are currently happening as we read this article? These athletes know how hard it is to succeed in their sport, and all they want is to get well in order to keep practicing and competing, so when they are faced with something like this, they fear. That is why a guy like Larry Nassar takes advantage of his position and the vulnerability of these women, to abuse them. Victims are never to blame, but the perpetrator themselves.

reply

09/04/2019

12:12 pm

Nadia Carrasco

This article was a crazy read. It really hurts my heart to hear about these stories and these men continuing to get away with their crimes. Larry Nassar deserve all his punishments and still would never understand the pain he put several girls through. Although this was a heavy topic the author made it easy to read and understand through all the details. The title is one of my favorites for sure. Great Job!!

reply

16/04/2019

12:12 pm

Auroara-Juhl Nikkels

I remember when this story was on the news. I was shocked to learn that so many young girls were sexually abused before anyone did anything. Things like this disgust me. SO many of the girls that went through this would not have had to had anyone listened to the girls’ stories. I can not imagine the pain that Gonzcar must have felt, realizing that her childhood escape was really a terrible person.

reply

17/04/2019

12:12 pm

Mia Morales

This is a very heartbreaking topic to read about, however it is important for it to be talked about to try and prevent more cases like this to occur. The women who came out to tell their stories are so brave and I genuinely pray they can grow from this experience. Congratulations on your nominations, this was a very well written article.

reply

19/04/2019

12:12 pm

Makenzie Santana

It hurts me to read about Larry Nassar and what he did to these poor girls, taking advantage of them, sexually abusing them. It hurts just enough for it to be one girl, let alone 499. Things like this have to be brought to the surface and men like Larry should never be able to get away with these disgusting actions. I am proud of those who were able to rise up and tell their story, and I am proud of the ones who didn’t but stay strong after experiencing what they did.

reply

21/04/2019

12:12 pm

Rebeca Escobar

I cannot imagine how hard it was to keep silent for such a long time and to find out how many other girls fell victim to Nassar’s abuse. We live in a time where many women are coming forward to speak up for themselves and the abuse they have suffered. I think this is such a huge step and very important, because it encourages other women to use their voice as well. I hope Nassar realizes what wrong he did, and that him being punished brings peace and closure to his victims.

reply

21/04/2019

12:12 pm

Maya Mani

I remember watching all the speeches of the victims. I can’t believe someone who was so accredited and in a position of taking care of people, could abuse this power. It’s so sickening that he targeted the younger girls, and got away with it for so many years. These girls trusted him as a doctor and he abused that trust and vulnerability, as well as his authority, to his advantage.

reply

21/04/2019

12:12 pm

Nathalie Figueroa Soto

It is absolutely shocking to read about how he was doing this for decades and yet he was only recently caught. Even though several women came forward, the accusations were always ignored because it was believed that Nassar was a good man with a “squeaky clean record.” Hearing about stories like this always terrifies me because it shows that sometimes victims can come forward and STILL be ignored. For all of the poor women who trusted and believed in him, who defended him, I can’t imagine the horror they must have gone through for years and years and I hope they all know that they are not to blame for his crimes.

reply

22/04/2019

12:12 pm

Engelbert Madrid

It is unfortunate that many girls were taken advantage by Larry Nassar, and that truly shows that some people use their position and authority to frighten young girls, so that they can abuse them. I find it crazy how Larry Nassar got away with it for so many years, and no other gymnastic coach knew about it. I don’t blame the victims, because they were the ones that were abuse, but their abuser were truly the ones that destroyed their lives.

reply

22/04/2019

12:12 pm

Tala Owens

I heard about this story but this article gave me more details. There was an overwhelming amount of girls who came forward and its sad that the at first no action was taken and the girls weren’t being taken seriously. It’s heartbreaking what he did those girls and for them to be able to reach out is very brave step its deeply upsetting that it took so long and so much for Nassar to receive the punishment he deserved.

reply

22/04/2019

12:12 pm

1 3 4 5

Leave a Reply