StMU Research Scholars

Featuring Scholarly Research, Writing, and Media at St. Mary's University
March 11, 2018

The Massacre at Columbine: How Boys Can Become Murderers

Winner of the Spring 2018 StMU History Media Award for

Best Article in the Category of “United States History”

Best Descriptive Article

It was April 20, 1999 in Littleton Colorado. Seventeen-year-old Eric Harris and his eighteen-year-old friend Dylan Klebold both drove separately on a Tuesday morning to play a couple of frames of bowling before heading off to school. Before departing in their black trench coats, the teens stuffed their backpacks and two duffle bags into the trunk of their cars. When they arrived at their school campus later that morning, the two adolescents proceeded into the school, carrying the duffel bags, which contained two propane bombs.1 They kept the bombs inside the duffel bags and carried them into the cafeteria, setting up the bombs throughout the room, where they were rigged to detonate at precisely 11:17 AM. After setting up the bombs, Eric and Dylan then proceeded back to the school parking lot, where they waited for the bombs to explode. The boys had grave intentions on that day. Their intentions were to shoot up their high school, resulting in the most destructive school shooting to ever occur in the United States at the time. Their high school is known as Columbine, the most famous high school in America, for the wrong reasons.2

Parking Lot of Columbine High School | Courtesy of Flickr

In January 1998, about a year before this horrific event unfolded, best friends Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold were suddenly surrounded by an aggressive and terrifying group of football players in the school cafeteria. The players proceeded to squirt ketchup packets at the two friends. Unable to fight back against the dominant jocks, Eric and Dylan were forced to wear their ketchup-stained clothes all day until they were able to go home from school. Around the cafeteria at Columbine, there were different classes of tables: the athletes had their table, and the weaker, outcast students had their table as well. While walking over to their table to sit at lunch, the athletes often threw skittles at Eric and Dylan and their outcast friends. While sitting at a lunch table with their few friends, the jocks kicked Eric and Dylan’s chairs, knocked their food trays down, and lunged food at them in the cafeteria. Bullying was not only a common occurrence to Eric and Dylan, but it also occurred to other students as well. Weaker students were shoved into lockers, called vile names, and also body slammed. They were the targets of the predators of the school. Everyone in the school, including Eric and Dylan, were afraid of the intimidating jocks, and for good reason. They were members of the trench coat mafia, which was a group that the two teens belonged to, which consisted of pro-Nazi outcasts, such as Eric and Dylan, and who also held a strong hatred for Christians. Their other trench coat mafia friends were able to shrug off the constant bullying. However, the same cannot be said about Eric and Dylan. The two friends took it in and absorbed it all, and their anger grew.3

As a result of the relentless harassment throughout Columbine, before going on a school-wide mass shooting spree, Eric Harris decided to dose on cough syrup, which he said, “is the best thing after a hard day of being called ‘gay’ by a schoolyard full of fashionable jocks and cheerleaders.”4 The two boys were outcasts of their school and members of this trench coat mafia subculture. At lunch for weeks, Eric and Dylan fantasized about blowing up the school, but because being harassed at Columbine was so common for outcast students, it was not unusual for students to speak of such outlandish events. So, when Eric and Dylan said this, other students did not believe they were serious; however, the intentions of the two teens were indeed grim and were not to be underestimated.5

The constant hatred towards his peers caused Eric to devise the plan of the shooting of his high school. Eric did most of the planning, while Dylan followed his lead and did what he said. Eric went into the cafeteria and observed when it was the most populated. He discovered that there were around 488 people inside the cafeteria at 11:17 a.m. Since this was the most populated time, they planned to bring two black duffel bags, each containing a propane tank that they would rig to explode at 11:17 a.m. In addition, they bought weapons, made bombs, and hid them in their trench coats and in the trunks of their cars. They carefully planned the terrible act for over a year prior to the shooting.6

After months and months of constant planning, Eric and Dylan were ready to put their diabolical plan into action. On April 20, 1999, around 11:20 AM, after placing the bombs in the cafeteria, Eric and Dylan were most likely bored of waiting in the parking lot for the bombs to explode. After the bombs failed to detonate around that time, the two adolescents began the destruction of their high school. They unzipped their trench coats, pulled out their guns, and opened fire in the parking lot of Columbine.7

Courtesy of Wikimedia Commons
Image of Rachel Scott, Christian Victim of Columbine | Courtesy of Wikimedia Commons

Outside of the school building on campus, seventeen-year-old Rachel Scott was eating lunch with her friend Richard Castaldo. Eric and Dylan came up to Rachel and Richard. The two shooters shot Richard multiple times in almost every part of his body, including his lungs. Then, they shot Rachel several times, hitting her thigh, left arm, and chest. They then turned their guns towards other fleeing students, shooting them as well. Rachel Scott laid on the ground, crying. Rachel, like many other victims of the shooting, was a Christian, which was the religion that the two pro-Nazi shooters despised. Eric went up to the poor and helpless Christian, and asked, “Do you believe in God?” Rachel said yes, and in response Eric said, “Then go be with Him,” and he shot her once again killing her.8 Rachel Scott died a martyr on that horrific day for her faith. Eric and Dylan resumed their carnage by entering into the school building itself. They went into the cafeteria, where most of the students had evacuated. While searching for students, the shooters began throwing bombs. Eric and Dylan then headed upstairs in the building. Coach Dave Sanders decided to stay back in the school to aid students, when Eric and Dylan ran into him. They shot Sanders in the back while he was fleeing, killing him instantly. After combing through the cafeteria, the shooters entered the library of Columbine, the deadliest room of the shooting. They began the bloodshed in the library by shooting behind the librarian’s desk. While in the commons, Eric and Dylan were taunting the students, yelling at them and cursing. They shouted at the horrified teens yelling, “All the jocks stand up!” They also targeted students who were wearing sports apparel. Isaiah Shoels was in the library on that nightmarish day. Isaiah was a football player at the school, which was not a good position to be in on April 20, 1999 at Columbine. Due to his African-American race, Eric and Dylan yelled racial slurs at Isaiah, and then they shot him. Unfortunately, there was more blood to be spilled. Eric then made his way towards Cassie Bernall, another Christian at Columbine, and asked her, “Do you believe in God”? Once again, just like Rachel Scott, Cassie firmly responded “yes,” and then they killed her. Just like Rachel Scott, Cassie Bernall became a martyr at the hands of Eric Harris while professing her faith. They did the same Christian interrogation to Val Schnurr, who admitted her faith and was killed for it. The outraged gunmen exited the commons, leaving ten students in the library shot in cold blood, and many others injured.9

Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold on a hunt in the cafeteria | Courtesy of Flickr’s The Commons

While roaming the school, the campus was being surrounded by police, ambulances, and even the National Guard. They knew they were not leaving that building alive. After deciding that there was nowhere else to run, Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold returned to the library, where they shot themselves in the head, putting an end to the bloody massacre of Columbine High School.10

The suicide of Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold may have seemed like a definite conclusion to the horrific shooting for some; however, for others, it was only just the beginning. Many families of those slaughtered victims at Columbine could not even begin to comprehend the weight of the situation. Many parents, whose sons or daughters became victims of the shooting, feared for their own marriages, let alone their mental status. One mother of one of the injured victims of the shooting committed suicide years later, due to her daughter being paralyzed and forced into a wheelchair for the rest of her life.11 However, despite the catastrophes of the families, to Eric and Dylan, this was a major success. They planned everything from entering the building, all the way to their own deaths. Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold were constantly harassed both physically and verbally to the point where they could no longer absorb any more humiliation and mistreatment from their peers. The constant bullying that the adolescents endured resulted in them dealing with severe depression disorders that few people were aware of. Even Dylan’s own parents were unaware of his suicidal behavior and of his ongoing depression at Columbine. Several arguments can be made about the cause of Columbine and what was truly going on inside the teens’ heads. Many claim the cause of the shooting was bullying, while others claim the shooting to be caused by the influence of violent video games, like “Doom,” and goth music artists, like Marilyn Manson. Whatever the true intentions of Eric and Dylan were, we will never seem to understand entirely. However, one point can be made about the disastrous shooting of Columbine on that horrid day. Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold had a specific goal: to exact revenge on the students of Columbine High School.

  1. UXL Encyclopedia of U.S. History, 2009, s.v. “Columbine High School Shooting,” by Sonia Benson.
  2. American Decades, 2004, s.v. “Analysis: What the Two Young Colorado Gunmen Were Really Like,” by Cynthia Rose.
  3. Perspectives on Modern World History, 2012, s.v. “Columbine High School Had a Serious Bullying Problem,” by Ralph W. Larkin.
  4. Perspectives on Modern World History, 2012, s.v. “Columbine High School Had a Serious Bullying Problem,” by Ralph W. Larkin.
  5. Ralph W. Larkin, Comprehending Columbine (Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 2007), 131.
  6. Ralph W. Larkin, Comprehending Columbine (Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 2007), 131.
  7.  Wendy Murray Zoba, “Do you Believe in God?” Christianity Today, October 1999.
  8. Life Focus, “Rachel Scott Life Focus Documentary”, 12:45-13:24, February 15 2016, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7M6MSM9o5Y4.
  9. Wendy Murray Zoba, “Do you Believe in God?” Christianity Today, October 1999.
  10. Wendy Murray Zoba, “Do you Believe in God?” Christianity Today, October 1999.
  11. US News and World Report, “Columbine Shooting: 10 Years Later,” 0:00-3:39, April 19, 2009, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5XTIOs4YK_c.

Timothy ODekirk

Author Portfolio Page

Recent Comments

239 comments

  • Jonathan Arreola

    I pray for all the people affected by the horrifying occurrence on April 20,1999. Altogether it is a despairing event, where I pity the victims and the aggressors. The effects of bullying are always terrible, leading young minds to act unreasonably and to the most extreme. In correspondence, the effects of violence always lead to death, and everlasting pain. I honestly can not put the blame all on Eric and Dylan, as the were abuse psychologically. I’m just hoping that strategies school have approached to prevent this from happening again will work.

  • This won an award for “best descriptive article”. Is that a synonym for “fiction”? Shockingly researched article, even more so that this passes for either academic rigor or “history” at a university. The range of references is extremely limited and overly weighted towards a Christian narrative, a case in point being the “martyrdom” layered onto the deaths of “three” of the victims.

    Cassie Bernall’s alleged martyrdom is disputed and the questions asked of Val Schnurr transposed to Cassie’s narrative (Source: https://newrepublic.com/article/122832/why-does-columbine-myth-about-martyr-cassie-bernall-persist)

    And, in fact, there weren’t three martyrs since Valeen did not die, as this article states: she survived. (Source: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2009/apr/12/columbine-massacre-ten-year-anniversary).

    Similarly, Dave Sanders, the varsity coach, was not killed outright, he survived for approximately three hours (Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Columbine_High_School_massacre#11:19_a.m.:_Shooting_begins)

    Anne Marie Hochhalter’s mother, Carla, who had pre-existing mental health issues, committed suicide six months after the Columbine Shootings (Source: https://www.usnews.com/education/articles/2009/04/17/a-survivors-story-10-years-after-columbine). Since I have used exactly the same source, the US News and World Report, though an article and not YouTube, as this author, I do wonder why the significant discrepancy.

    I could go on, and provide countless more sources to validate every point I make, not least about the unhelpfulness of emotive assumptions such as the gunmen were “outraged” in a theoretically academic piece. I assume the intent is one of factual reportage because of the presence of references. Outraged, really? Because of their antipathy to religion? That’s the inference. However, countless witness accounts record that they whooped and hollered – plenty of enjoyment on their part. If they were outraged, I would suggest that it was instead the cold rage – of the narcissist/psychopath and the depressive perhaps – and nothing to do with Christianity.

    All-in-all, the dissemination of myth and bias masquerading as historical truth really isn’t good academic practice.

  • Robert Freise

    Growing up and learning about school safety and things students would have to do if there was a active shooter on campus were heavily addressed growing up for me. When I was a younger kid I learned about the Columbine Massacre that happened in Littleton, Colorado. It gave me a realization that this is no fairy tale world and things like this can happen on any given day. I have always wondered what went through Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold’s mind’s leading up to the massacre and during it. It is crazy to think that a combination of bullying and a unstable household could drive these teens to the edge and what in their head triggered them to take so many lives. Great article!!

  • Brianna Ford

    Reading this article gave my body chills. I knew of the event, but this article gave me some information that I never knew happened. The fact that they took a year to plan this unbelievable event is just completely horrible. It is so horrible that they targeted people who believed in God. They were killed for something that they believed in. I also don’t know how they were able to create man-made bombs with out no suspicion… where were the parents? However, what makes me mad is that they killed themselves. They got the easy way out and didn’t get punished for the crimes that they committed. This is a story that breaks my heart, however this was very good detailed article about the horrific event.

  • Richard Morales

    The Columbine Massacre was an event that chilled my soul when I originally learned about it. This article gave me more reasoning behind that awful day. I didn’t know the extent to which the two shooters were harassed. This highlights the problem of bullying in American schools. Although no amount of torment should result in a school shooting students must respect there peers and look out for fellow classmates if they notice them being picked on.

  • Devin Ramos

    The columbine shooting was planned to every detail which is crazy to me because other mass shooters do not put this much planning into their acts. The boys Eric and Dylan planned this for a year and to my knowledge of right now I cannot think of any other shootings that were planned for this long. The boys were bullied by I think this should not be an excuse for murdering people. One thing that I did not know at all about the shooting was that the boys would ask someone if they believed in God before shooting the person.

  • Pamela Callahan

    While the event described in this article is horrific, the way the author told the story and explained all of the details was very interesting and helped me envision the terror and chaos of the situation. I can’t imagine what it must have been like to have been effected by such a violent tragedy. While I wish that no one in the world would ever have to experience the pain that the families of the victims have to endure, I also wish that no one ever had to face the constant bullying that those two boys, and so many others, were forced to live through on a daily basis.

  • Avery Looney

    This article is very well written and researched. The author goes into great detail of the the two shooters, Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold, background and the way the planned the shooting. School shootings have become a major problem in our society, and needs to come to an end. It is sickening that people will go to the lengths that Harris and Klebold went to make a point. Even if the pair were bulled, there is no excuse for their actions. School is a place where everyone should feel safe and welcomed, but that is not the case anymore.

  • Maisie Favila

    The Columbine shooting was one of the most horrific tragedies. I find it unbelievable that there was such an amount of damage caused because something possessed them to do it. Although I don’t think it was fair that they were bullied, I don’t feel like it is in any form of way an ‘excuse’ for what they did. I liked the article because I wasn’t aware that they would ask the people they would kill if they believed in God. I found that disturbing but I felt that I needed to know that information to know more about the case.

  • Lamont Traylor

    It is so sad how tragedies such as columbine happen in America. People cannot feel safe anywhere these days, people shoot up movie theaters, schools, and even a innocent video game tournament was shot up by someone. I don’t know when or how this will ever stop, but somehow someway these things need to stop happening for the sake of the next generations to come.

Leave your comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.