StMU Research Scholars

Featuring Scholarly Research, Writing, and Media at St. Mary’s University

October 2, 2019

Phineas Gage: An Ordinary Man

It was not an extraordinary day in Cavendish, Vermont. To most people, this day was perfectly normal. September 13, 1848 was just another Wednesday. Phineas Gage, a foreman working for Rutland & Burlington Railroad, would have agreed that this day was no different from any other. Or, at least that’s how it started.1

On this day in September 1848, Gage was only 25 years old. Gage, by all means, was not extraordinary. He was very average. He stood at 5 feet 6 inches, and he was physically strong, as was needed for his job. He was kind, well-mannered, intelligent, and had a good temper. On this day, Gage was putting explosive powder into an iron.  It was part of his job, and something he had done before. Gage, a cautious man, usually paid attention to what he was doing. For some reason, he turned his head for a second. He looked away. That was all it took. In one second, his life changed forever.2

The powder Gage was putting into the iron activated, causing an explosion. Surprised, he didn’t have a time to react. The force blew him from where he was standing, and he landed a couple of feet away from his original position. The iron rod went through his left cheek and then out of his skull. Days later it was found by Gage’s men, about 80 feet away from where Gage landed, smeared with blood and brain.3

Simulated rendering of Gage’s skull | Courtesy of Wikipedia

Miraculously, Gage didn’t pass out from the impact or the bleeding. He got up, went to the town, went into a hotel, and waited there for a doctor. All with little help. When the local doctor arrived, Gage spoke to him and said, “Doctor, here is business enough for you.” Dr. Williams couldn’t believe him — if his story was true and an iron went through his head, how was Gage still standing and talking? How was he fully conscious? It wasn’t until an Irishman standing nearby added to their conversation, stating the rod was still on the floor over by the railroad, “all blood and bits,” that Dr. William believed him.4

Dr. Williams, realizing he wasn’t exactly qualified to treat Gage’s injury called over Dr. John Harlow. In today’s terms, calling Dr. Harlow a neurosurgeon wouldn’t be correct. At this time, neuroscience wasn’t even known, much less an actual field of study. Still, Dr. Harlow treated Gage and managed to stop the hemorrhage Gage had.  Even though Phineas Gage experienced severe trauma, he didn’t seem very bothered, nor did he show any signs of stress. Gage even told the doctor that he didn’t want his friends or family to come visit him. After all, his accident wasn’t very serious, and he would return to work in a couple of days time. Through this process, Gage was conscious, and the traces left by the iron and rust were a testament to his accident.5

It took a while for Gage to recover. Not surprisingly. Dr. Harlow kept a clear record of his whole treatment. He kept an almost day-by-day journal filled with his observations, as well as the treatment Gage was receiving. He had an infection, but as Dr. Harlow treated it, it went away fairly quickly. At times during his recovery, Gage would sometimes seem delirious, but that would clear up almost immediately. It was remarkable.6 Really, no one would have guessed what was truly wrong with him until they analyzed him fully. On top of his head, there was an inverted tunnel showing where the rod had come out of. On his left cheek, there was a hole. Small pieces of Gage’s brain appeared scattered throughout his scalp, stuck to his hair. Dr. Harlow described in his report later on, that as he pressed against Gage’s skull, “The pulsations of the brain were distinctly seen and felt.”7 A month later, Gage was able to stand and walk around. Neurologically, he appeared in tact.

A Boston Post article on Gage’s accident, September 21, 1848 | Courtesy of Wikipedia

The news of his accident quickly spread.  Soon enough, Gage was the main topic for articles in his town. This, however, was not what lead to his fame, in fact, Gage wasn’t exactly flourishing after this accident. It was the opposite.

Physically, he wasn’t much different than before. He was still physically capable, although his left eye would stay shut forever, and the left side of his face was partially paralyzed.8 Dr. Harlow would even go so far as to say he had fully recovered. Gage stated he felt fine, but he had an odd feeling. But, it was a feeling not even he could describe. He had no pain, but something was different in his head.9

Phineas Gage holding the iron rod | Courtesy of Wikipedia

Even though he was physically capable of doing most things, he couldn’t hold down a job. His old employer refused to hire him again. Something had changed, and it wasn’t in Gage’s physical performance.  After the accident everyone collectively agreed, “Gage was no longer Gage.”10 Dr. Harlow detailed these changes. Reportedly, Gage’s personality and behavior drastically changed. The capable and efficient man people hired and knew was gone. He was replaced by a different type of man. Gage now used profanity, something he hadn’t done before. He showed little emotion or care for his coworkers and previous friends.  He was irrational, with a short temper.11

The announcement for Gage’s act from August 1852 in Vermont | Courtesy of Wikipedia

Years after the accident, Gage continued to find himself unemployed. His ill-advised decisions caused by his new personality didn’t land him very far. Instead, Gage sought other ways to make money.12 He exhibited himself as a circus act, carrying the famous iron rod. Of course, every job he held was short lived, and he wasn’t a circus act his whole life. He also traveled traveled. He went from through New England, all the way to Chile. His jobs were mostly manual types of work, like driving a stagecoach. Throughout all his travels, he carried the rod with him, like it was a part of him, his only companion.13

In 1860, at the young age of 36, Gage began to experience seizures.  He returned home to California, where he reunited with his mother and sister, his only family. Dr. Harlow would later report that after every epileptic convulsion, Gage had no memory of them. Eventually, on May 21st, 1860, after a series of continuous seizures, Phineas Gage died. It was exactly, “twelve years, six months and eight days after the date of his injury.”14

Portrait of Phineas Gage | Courtesy of Wikipedia

Phineas Gage’s story, as well as the later exhumation of his bones, led to the discovery and subsequent explorations of the brain. His story is one that’s commonly looked at, and it is referred to as “Neuroscience’s most famous case.”15 It led to advancements in what we now know about brain injuries, and how to treat them. Still, sometimes Phineas Gage himself is forgotten. He should be remembered not just as a case, or as an interesting phenomenon, but as a person. He was a good-looking, kind, confident, assertive, young man.16 He had a family, friends, and lived a good life. He was an ordinary man, who experienced an extraordinary injury. And, we should never forget him for that.

  1. John Martyn Harlow, “Recovery from the passage of an iron bar through the head,” Publications of the Massachusetts Medical Society 2, no. 3 (1868): 4.
  2. John Martyn Harlow, “Recovery from the passage of an iron bar through the head,” Publications of the Massachusetts Medical Society 2, no. 3 (1868): 4.
  3. TL Guidotti, “Phineas Gage and His Frontal Lobe- The “American Crowbar Case”,” Archives of Environmental & Occupational Health 67, no. 4 (2012): 249.
  4. Malcolm Macmillan, Odd Kind of Fame: Stories of Phineas Gage (Cambridge: MIT Press, 2000), 43-44.
  5. John Martyn Harlow, “Recovery from the passage of an iron bar through the head,” Publications of the Massachusetts Medical Society 2, no. 3 (1868): 7.
  6. Andrew Grieve, “Phineas P Gage—‘The man with the Iron bad’,” Trauma 12, no 3 (2010): 172.
  7. John Martyn Harlow, “Recovery from the passage of an iron bar through the head,” Publications of the Massachusetts Medical Society 2, no. 3 (1868): 5.
  8. TL Guidotti, “Phineas Gage and His Frontal Lobe- The “American Crowbar Case”,” Archives of Environmental & Occupational Health 67, no. 4 (2012): 249-250.
  9. John Martyn Harlow, “Recovery from the passage of an iron bar through the head,” Publications of the Massachusetts Medical Society 2, no. 3 (1868): 12.
  10. TL Guidotti, “Phineas Gage and His Frontal Lobe- The “American Crowbar Case”,” Archives of Environmental & Occupational Health 67, no. 4 (2012): 249-250.
  11. John Martyn Harlow, “Recovery from the passage of an iron bar through the head,” Publications of the Massachusetts Medical Society 2, no. 3 (1868): 11-12.
  12. Encylopedia of Social Psychology, 2007, s.v. “Social Cognitive Neuroscience,” by Matthew D. Lieberman.
  13. TL Guidotti, “Phineas Gage and His Frontal Lobe- The “American Crowbar Case”,” Archives of Environmental & Occupational Health 67, no. 4 (2012): 249-250.
  14. John Martyn Harlow, “Recovery from the passage of an iron bar through the head,” Publications of the Massachusetts Medical Society 2, no. 3 (1868): 14.
  15. Andrew Grieve, “Phineas P Gage—‘The man with the Iron bad’,” Trauma 12, no 3 (2010): 173.
  16. TL Guidotti, “Phineas Gage and His Frontal Lobe- The “American Crowbar Case”,” Archives of Environmental & Occupational Health 67, no. 4 (2012): 250.

Tags from the story

Dr. John Martin Harlow

iron bar

Medicine

neuroscience

Phineas Gage

psychology

railroad

Stephanie Cerda

I am a Psychology and Criminology major at St. Mary’s University in San Antonio, Texas, graduating class of 2023. I’m from Houston, Texas. I enjoy taking a deeper look into human behavior, as well as analyzing how the world works. I love to spend time with my friends and family, and my passion is in learning. I believe there’s always more to discover.

Author Portfolio Page

Recent Comments

Azucena Cuevas

I recently learned about Phineas Gage during my psychology class. I think that it’s insane how he survived such a terrible incident. His aftermath is still terrible. It brought awareness of the effects of damage to the frontal lobe can have. I found it interesting how his whole personality changed due to the incident and his ability to control his emotions diminished.

reply

02/10/2019

8:26 pm

Michael Lazcano

Phineas Gage is a man discussed in my most recent psychology class, but also in my previous psychology classes I had taken in high school. I still can’t imagine how someone could survive such a brain injury of that magnitude, but I guess the body is resilient and neurogenesis may have played a part in the recovery. It is also fascinating how the frontal lobe is connected to the personality go people, and how any damage can change someones overall personality. This may also give us incite into such mental disorders or the growing cases of CTE and how it affects football players emotions and such. Phineas Gage gave us a better picture of how the brain works, even if it’s still a big mystery.

reply

03/10/2019

8:26 pm

Vania Gonzalez

The name Phineas Gage sounded familiar when I read the title of the article but I could not put it together. This is very interesting and I think I have read a case on him. It is very unusual that he survived this trauma especially with no serious injuries that left him paralyzed or brain dead and at a time when they were not as advanced as we are now in medicine. Interesting topic I really enjoyed it.

reply

03/10/2019

8:26 pm

Juan Arceo

I have never heard about Phineas Cage, but I am glad that this article introduced me to him. It is fascinating to see that this man, who for a split second, looked away and all of a sudden had an iron rod through his head, and survived to tell the tale. If this event seems shocking to us, just imagine how confused the doctors were? According to the article they have never seen anything like this and who could blame them. It is sad that after this event his personality changed and basically was a different man due to the damage that happened with his head.

reply

03/10/2019

8:26 pm

Lindsey Wieck

Congrats on publishing this article! This was a perfect topic for this kind of article, and you wrote it beautifully. Way to go!

reply

03/10/2019

8:26 pm

Aaron Peters

Congrats on getting your article published! I remember reading a little about Gage in my psychology class a few years ago, I was surprised how drastically different Gage was after the accident, or that he was able to live a long time after being impaled through the skull. It certainly was one of the more interesting ways to study how changes to the brain could affect someone’s personality.

reply

04/10/2019

8:26 pm

Jake Mares

Imagine surviving a metal rod sticking through your skull and still remaining calm about it. Today, this sounds like something straight out a superhero movie. Not only does this make for interesting speculations about whether his brain being tampered lead to his change in ways, but it also ignited the neuroscience field, something we feel is important today.

reply

04/10/2019

8:26 pm

Eliezer Leal

This was a great article about this truly insane story. Surviving and explosion not even a foot away from you is crazy to think about, but surviving and explosion that close with a five foot rod going through your skull is unbelievable. Phineas’ story is remarkable, being able to survive such trauma, although with that amount of damage to such a delicate and intricate organ such as the brain, it goes without saying there would be side effects. As said in the article if it had not been for Mr. Gage neurosciences might not be what it is today.

reply

04/10/2019

8:26 pm

Charli Delmonico

This article amazed me. I can’t believe that gage was able to undergo such trauma and still walk himself to a place where he could be treated. I don’t understand how that is even possible. I also can’t believe that he lived for twelve years after that. His ability to live after having a rod go through his head is remarkable and incredibly surprising. The rod must have hit him just right to where he was still able to live and function afterwards.

reply

04/10/2019

8:26 pm

Thalia Romo

The story of Phineas Gage is very interesting, I’m not too into medical stories, not a big fan of hearing about blood and body parts, however this story was highly interesting and kept my attention thoroughly. I don’t find it strange that Phineas’ personality seemed to change due to the fact that he underwent neurological trauma that more than likely sparked that. However, that fact that Phineas kept the rod and sort of paraded it around is very interesting and yet sickening.

reply

04/10/2019

8:26 pm

1 2 3

Leave a Reply