StMU Research Scholars

Featuring Scholarly Research, Writing, and Media at St. Mary's University
April 12, 2026

Defense, Deficits, and the Cost of Poland’s Growing Regional Leadership

Poland transitions to center stage

“Ukrainians are fleeing Russian aggression” |
Courtesy of  Wikimedia Commons February 27, 2022.

Poland did not use to make headlines in Europe after COVID weakened it so badly. However, when Russia attacked its neighbor, Ukraine, it brought Poland to the heart of European security, giving it the opportunity to boost its leadership. Poland’s economy had started growing after the pandemic, but Russia’s invasion of Ukraine brought on many new challenges. This article explores the consequences of the war in Ukraine and how these have affected Poland – from the numerous Russian attacks on Poland’s energy infrastructure, to economic instability via inflation – and how despite these circumstances, Poland has managed to reclaim its place as a regional power.

In this period of transition, what are the solutions Polish leadership worked on to avoid a deeper  economic and security crisis? Poland’s response to the war—characterized by having opened its doors to millions of migrants,- then it implemented an aggressive strategy for decoupling from Russian energy, and facilitating massive military aid to Ukraine. Poland redefined its role in the European project and its own national security mission.

How many refugees are enough?

The minimum salary has increased along with average salary.
Credits: AI Gemini (Nano Banana)

Poland borders the Eastern side of Ukraine—Poland has received close to 3.5 million persons who arrived between February 24, 2022 and mid-May that same year.1 This influx in migration of Ukrainians saturated the labor market at a time when Poland still lacked any real integration plan. Three and a half million refugees, with over 95% Ukrainian nationals, arrived in Poland fleeing the Russian invasion.2 Three and a half million people in three months – that is the scale of the shock to their infrastructure, economy, and even perhaps culture that Poland absorbed. Prior to the 2022 invasion and the subsequent surge of refugees from Ukraine, Poland did not have a comprehensive integration policy in place with measures dedicated to refugees. The National Recovery and Resilience Plan (Krakowy Plan Obdudowy- KPO) development strategy drafted to recover from the Covid economic downturn in Poland received EU approval and substantial financing to rebuild and develop Poland’s economy.3 Not only was Poland expecting to increase its revenue from outside resources, but also hoping domestic investors and corporations would reinvest their profits in 2026. In the 3rd quarter in 2025, exports grew by 6.1% which added 0.2 percentage to the Gross Domestic Product (GDP).4 Clearly, the large influx of migrant has had a positive impact even if very small on their GDP at first.

Honeymoon period for Ukrainian Refugees will soon end

“Conservative-nationalist Polish President Karol Nawrocki [stated that] “Poles feel… that our effort, our multifaceted assistance to Ukraine since the beginning of the full-scale invasion has not been duly appreciated or understood”.”5 Poland’s new leadership has expressed reservations regarding ongoing support for Ukrainian refugees. President Karol Nawrocki emphasized a nation-first approach during his campaign, highlighting priorities for Polish citizens. He has also characterized some Ukrainian refugees as “ungrateful” and as putting a strain on societal resources.6 This stance reflects a strategic effort to reassess refugee assistance programs. President Nawrocki stated that what he called an “incomprehensible and unacceptable situation” where foreigners receive aid without equivalent contribution. The government has announced that they will now gradually phase out these exceptional measures and transition from temporary solutions to more permanent, systemic ones. They contend that Ukrainians are now sufficiently integrated to be treated similarly to other foreign nationals. Currently, 46% of Poles oppose accepting Ukrainian refugees, compared to only 3% at the beginning of the conflict. Under the previous system, employers could easily hire Ukrainian workers; however, new requirements for work permits will introduce additional bureaucratic delays. This shift prioritizes political messaging over labor market considerations, despite opposition from employers, who note that Ukrainians constitute approximately 66% of Poland’s immigrant workforce. Collectively, these factors give the new administration both an ideological reason and a political win for ending the special benefits.7

Poland plans concluding the special legal status previously granted to Ukrainian nationals following Russia’s full-scale invasion in 2022. Under the 2022 special legislation, Ukrainians were permitted to enter Poland without a visa, remain legally without applying for asylum, and receive automatic temporary protection. These provisions are now being phased out, requiring Ukrainians to apply for standard residence permits, work permits, or other immigration channels. Additionally, the program providing free accommodation, subsidized housing, and payments to Polish families hosting refugees is being reduced or discontinued. Access to social benefits such as child allowances, family support, disability assistance, and one-time cash payments is also being restricted, aligning Ukrainians’ status with that of other non-EU migrants rather than protected refugees. While free access to the public healthcare system—covering emergency and routine medical services—has been available, this will now be scaled back, potentially necessitating insurance, employer coverage, or out-of-pocket payments. Although children remain eligible to attend school, as mandated by Polish law, the specialized support programs—including free language classes, integration services, and psychological support for children affected by war—are being reduced amid the policy changes. Initially, during the early stages of the conflict, Ukrainians benefited from temporary measures such as free public transport, food vouchers, emergency cash, and humanitarian aid packages. These programs are now coming to an end as the government considers the “emergency phase” to be over. Ukrainians will now be treated the same way any other third-country nationals immigrants to Poland would, rather than as protected refugees. 8

Energy independence fuels strength

Poland has achieved full independence from Russian coal and gas imports. By 2024, the share of Russian raw materials in Poland’s energy supply had been reduced to zero, compared to 52% for gas and 7% for coal in 2015.9 The less Polish rely on other countries its energy the more power it harnesses. Poland has developed a coherent national energy strategy sometimes at odds with the EU.

Visually emphasizing that economic growth has decoupled from resource consumption and emissions.
Credits: Kacper Kwidziński, Marcin Dusiło and AI Gemini
10
In the graph above, we can see how over the past 2 decades Poland has increased its crude oil consumption while reducing its coal consumption and reducing its greenhouse gas emissions.11 Poland has also moved to diversifying its imports of oil.12 While in the past over 89% of its crude oil came from Russia. As early as 2016, two years after Russia invaded Crimea, Poland moved to diversify its sources of oil imports. The European Council on Foreign Relations explains in this chart how much and how quickly Poland effectively when from almost complete dependency on Russia to having the ability to manage multiple sources and international partners.13

Conclusion: Poland: A Regional Power Reborn

Will Poland’s move to cutting benefits for the 3.5 million Ukrainians impact Poland’s economy negatively? And in doing so will the weakened Polish economy also diminish their leadership? Yes, Poland’s ending of services for Ukrainian refugees and adding more steps for their continued employment will likely negatively impact Poland’s economy. President Nawrocki has a political motive where they no longer prioritize helping as a humanitarian imperative but are using this issue for personal political gains.

Poland is no longer just a border state but the geopolitical center of gravity for the European defense of Ukraine. Poland’s geography gave it a very important edge in the securing Europe’s fight against Russia. Poland welcomed Ukrainians which helped rebuild and grow its own economy. Now, might Russia decide to invade Poland?  On the one hand, Russia has been struggling to invade Ukraine and has still not finished the job. Vast areas of Ukrainian territory have remained free of Russian control if not free from Russia strikes. On the other hand, Russia has failed to meet its early military objective of colonizing Ukraine. Would Russia decide to attack Poland to prevent Ukrainians and Poles from keeping the life line of support for Ukraine’s resistance in place? Would Russia only be able to overwhelm Ukraine by cutting off its border to Poland as well?

How or who can stop Russia? NATO’s emerging “East Shield” architecture signifies a strategic shift toward a layered, multi-domain defense posture aimed at deterring, disrupting, and slowing potential Russian aggression along the Alliance’s northeastern border.14 According to the International Institute for Strategic Studies, Poland’s fortification efforts—integrated with the Baltic Defence Line and Finland’s enhanced border defenses—do not present an impenetrable barrier but instead provide operational friction for Russian forces through obstacles, surveillance networks, and integrated air defense systems. These measures seek to delay an initial attack sufficiently for NATO’s forward-deployed units and rapid reinforcement plans to mobilize, while also addressing Russia’s increasing use of grey-zone tactics such as UAV incursions, sabotage, and electronic and cyber warfare. 14 The military cooperation, East Shield, coordinates and organizes the protective operations, bolsters defensive posturing, and guarantees that any attempt by Russian to invade on another front would face both clear prompt opposition with a rapid escalation with NATO’s involvement, even if the US might not join.

 

 

 

  1. Maciej Duszczyk and Paweł Kaczmarczyk. “The War in Ukraine and Migration to Poland: Outlook and Challenges.” Intereconomics, 2022.
  2. Maciej Duszczyk and Paweł Kaczmarczyk, “The War in Ukraine and Migration to Poland: Outlook and Challenges,” Intereconomics, 2022.
  3. Center for European Cooperation, Cedefop, European Union, 2026. This is a decentralized agency of the EU by “Regulation (EU) 2019/128 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 16 January 2019 establishing a European Centre for the Development of Vocational Training (Cedefop)” and repealing Council Regulation (EEC) No 337/75.
  4. Marek Skawiński and Michał Kulbacki. “4% GDP growth. Inflation on target. Forecasts for Poland’s economy in 2026.”XYZ, 03.01.2026.
  5. President Karol Nawrocki quoted inside of AFP, “Poland phases out aid for Ukrainian refugees” Reuters, March 5, 2026.
  6. Karen Hargrave, Kseniya Homel, and Lenka Dražanová, 2023, “History of migration in Poland.” In Public narratives and attitudes towards refugees and other migrants: Poland country profile.
  7. RFI. “Ukraine Crisis – Ukrainian Refugees Face Uncertain Future as Poland Scraps Special Status.” Radio France Internationale, March 5, 2026.
  8. Klaus Witold  and Monika Szulecka, “Departing or Being Deported? Poland’s Approach towards Humanitarian Migrants,” Journal of Refugee Studies 36, no. 3 (2023): 467–88, https://doi.org/10.1093/jrs/feac063.
  9. Kacper Kwidziński and Marcin Dusiło. “Energy Transition in Poland. Edition 2025.”Forum Energii, 30 July 2025.
  10. European Council on Foreign Relations, 12/23/2024, “Empowering Poland, the Role of International Partnerships,” https://ecfr.eu/publication/empowering-poland-the-role-of-international-partnerships/.
  11. Szymon Kardaś, (2023), From Coal to Consensus: Poland’s Energy Transition and its European Future, European Council on Foreign Relations.
  12. European Council on Foreign Relations, 12/23/2024, “Empowering Poland, the Role of International Partnerships,” https://ecfr.eu/publication/empowering-poland-the-role-of-international-partnerships/.
  13. European Council on Foreign Relations, 12/23/2024, “Empowering Poland, the Role of International Partnerships,” https://ecfr.eu/publication/empowering-poland-the-role-of-international-partnerships/.
  14. International Institute for Strategic Studies. “Fortifying NATO’s Eastern Flank.” The Military Balance 2026. Accessed April 10, 2026. https://www.iiss.org/publications/the-military-balance/2026/the-military-balance-2026/fortifying-natos-eastern-flank/.
  15. International Institute for Strategic Studies. “Fortifying NATO’s Eastern Flank.” The Military Balance 2026. Accessed April 10, 2026. https://www.iiss.org/publications/the-military-balance/2026/the-military-balance-2026/fortifying-natos-eastern-flank/.

Elizabeth Vazquez

Author Portfolio Page

Recent Comments

Leave the first comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.