StMU Research Scholars

Featuring Scholarly Research, Writing, and Media at St. Mary’s University

May 12, 2021

How COVID-19 amplified the racial disparities in the U.S. healthcare system by further limiting language access

On the evening of April 4, 2020, Dr. Ramon Tallaj and partnered physicians worked to assist a Spanish-speaking undocumented man. Prior to seeking medical assistance, the man had shared on Facebook what kept him from getting help sooner: the belief that an attempt to get tested for COVID-19 as an undocumented person would result in a fine.1

Fortunately, Dr. Tallaj and his physician-led performance provider network called SOMOS Community Care work with over 650,000 patients in underserved communities across New York City, primarily Asian and Hispanic immigrants.2 Such networks were birthed to address multiple disparities in the United States’ health system that have led to a disproportionate amount of COVID-19 deaths in the Hispanic/Latino population: the lack of access to languages other than English for health professionals to provide for their patients. 

In New York where SOMOS operates, Latinos make up 29% of the population and have the largest number of COVID-19 cases and deaths per 100,000 than their counterparts.3 In the entire U.S., Hispanic/Latinos come second to White Non-Hispanics in the amount of COVID-19 cases and deaths reported to the CDC. See Figure 1.4

Figure 1. | Data on COVID-19 cases and deaths reported separated by Race/Ethnicity. | Table Courtesy of CDC.gov

 

The COVID-19 pandemic has exposed the health inequity experienced by individuals with limited English proficiency (LEP) in the United States. These language deficiencies include scarce data on patient language and ethnicity, limited availability of language appropriate services such as interpreting, and the lack of language-concordant healthcare professionals.5

Salome Mwangi, a Kenyan who relocated to Boise, Idaho, through a refugee resettlement program, is a medical interpreter for patients who speak Kiswahili. In March 2020, at the beginning of the pandemic, Mwangi was told to cancel all her interpretation appointments because the clinics and doctors’ offices would opt for a third-party vendor to provide virtual interpreting instead. However, Mwangi said that this method of interpreting is inefficient because of dialectal nuances and the non-verbal aspect of communication that cannot be translated over the phone or in video. “If I’m talking to you over the phone, there may be body language you’re exhibiting that I might not be able to read,” Mwangi told Time.6

That same month, ProPublica reported on a woman who arrived at an overrun emergency room of a hospital in Brooklyn. The woman didn’t speak English, and was placed in a unit designated for patients that didn’t have COVID-19. Days later, a doctor saw that she had a cough and fever and needed to be treated for the virus. “Good luck. She speaks Hungarian,” he told the COVID-19 unit employees. The woman died the next night.7

A medical resident who treated the same Hungarian woman also spoke to ProPublica. He believed that the woman would have gotten better care if she had spoken English. According to the resident, no one in the emergency room wanted to work with an interpreter to communicate with the woman and collect her medical history. Instead, the medical resident dialed an interpreter service on the phone and he placed the phone on the Hungarian woman’s shoulder, which posed its own issues of comprehension, considering the N95 mask the medical resident wore over his mouth and helmet that covered his ears. For several minutes the medical resident shouted into the phone that the patient needed a Hungarian speaker. “It takes 10 minutes of sitting on the phone to get an interpreter, and that’s valuable time when you’re inundated,” the resident told ProPublica. “So this utilitarian calculus kicks in. And the patients that are most mainstream get the best care.”8

10 ways to manage COVID-19 symptoms at home. | Graphic Courtesy of CDC.gov

 

Interpretation services, both in-person and over-the-phone, were already limited in hospitals prior to the pandemic due to the cost and time constraints. The overfilling of hospitals with COVID-19 patients and reduction of in-person professional interpreters only amplified this lack of access.9

Last month, the National Health Law Program along with Department of Health and Human Services Office for Civil Rights (OCR), the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), and the Department of Homeland Security Office for Civil Rights and Civil Liberties filed a civil rights complaint over discriminatory provision of COVID-19 services to persons with Limited English Proficiency. The National Health Law Program collected information from more than 35 organizations and individuals across the U.S. that led them to call for immediate action on this nationwide problem. The complaint outlines a number of steps agencies could take in order to address the language access barriers, including advising hospitals and doctors’ offices not to use automated translation software and prioritize the use of in-person interpretation.10

“Everyone in this country has a right to meaningful access to health care in a language they understand, whether they are an Arabic-speaker in Michigan or a Korean-speaker in Georgia,” said senior attorney Priscilla Huang in the complaint. “Our complaint describes numerous situations where health officials failed to provide needed services. Even in a place as diverse as the City and County of Los Angeles, much of the COVID assistance has only been provided in English, or when provided in other languages translated using auto-translate applications. These auto-translators are notoriously inaccurate, and this is especially true when translating medical and technical information. Officials even used these applications to translate information into Spanish, despite ample evidence early in the pandemic that Latino communities were being disproportionately impacted.”11

For LEP patients, the access to medical information in their language could be the difference between life and death. Language barriers between LEP patients and their health care professionals have shown to have a direct impact on the quality of their treatment, as seen previously with Hungarian woman who did not receive proper care due to the bad quality of the translation services. LEP patients who have access to language-concordant care through adequate language services such as trained professional interpreters are proven to have better clinical outcomes than those without access.12

CDC Spanish billboard in Union Station, Washington, DC. Photo by Elvert Barnes. | Photo Courtesy of Flickr

 

Experts argue that the reduced access to language services in the public health system could be solvable by increasing the number of physicians who speak languages other than English. This would create a more efficient and timely manner in which patients could engage in communication and be treated. Medical Spanish coursework is available in over 50% of medical schools in the U.S., but few schools require standardized tests or evaluations of the Spanish skills learned. Research shows that while senior medical students with Spanish skills may feel inhibited from interpreting depending on their Spanish skill levels, they rarely refuse to interpret when caring for LEP patients.13

“At the free clinic, I had the opportunity to interpret for Mexican lady undergoing seizures. I interpreted for both the medical student and attending taking care of her. There were no problems with the interpretation and all, the healthcare providers as well as the patient were thankful to have someone they could communicate with,” said a senior medical student. “I interpret all the time for my patients because I want them to have all their questions answered. It is essential I think to be able to be bilingual in some other language because of the diverse patient population. This helps alleviate some of the barriers in medicine.”14

Where the Health National Law Program’s Civil Rights complaint addresses the failures of federal, state, and local agencies to provide LEP individuals quality access to COVID-19 services, according to experts, at the core of health equity for linguistic minorities is language access. This can be addressed by providing physicians with high-quality medical Spanish education.15

The COVID-19 pandemic has shown that a lack of language concordance for LEP individuals and Spanish language patients in the U.S. could be the difference between life and death. Attending the limited language access is just one way to remedy the racial disparities in the U.S. health system that keep minority populations in the U.S. from receiving proper medical care.16

  1. Aguilera, J. (2020, April 15). Coronavirus patients who don’t speak English could end up ‘Unable to communicate in their last moments of life.’ Time. https://time.com/5816932/coronavirus-medical-interpreters/
  2.  Ramon Tallaj, M.D. – Chairman of the Board. (n.d.). SOMOS. https://somoscommunitycare.org/who-we-are/ramon-tallaj/
  3.  Despres, C. (2021, April 20). Update: Coronavirus case rates and death rates for Latinos in the United States. Salud America. https://salud-america.org/coronavirus-case-rates-and-death-rates-for-latinos-in-the-united-states/
  4.  CDC. (2020, December 10). COVID-19 racial and ethnic health disparities. https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/community/health-equity/racial-ethnic-disparities/increased-risk-illness.html
  5.  Ortega, P., Shin, T. M., Pérez-Cordón, C., & Martínez, G. A. (2020). Virtual medical Spanish education at the corazón of Hispanic/Latinx health During COVID-19. Medical Science Educator, 30(4), 1661–1666. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40670-020-01058-0
  6. Aguilera, J. (2020, April 15). Coronavirus patients who don’t speak English could end up ‘Unable to communicate in their last moments of life.’ Time. https://time.com/5816932/coronavirus-medical-interpreters/
  7.  Kaplan, J. (2020, March 31). Hospitals have left many COVID-19 patients who don’t speak English alone, confused and without proper care. ProPublica. https://www.propublica.org/article/hospitals-have-left-many-covid19-patients-who-dont-speak-english-alone-confused-and-without-proper-care?token=jg6nGk6aRoymOqJmDTSthj1PIBKaGEW9
  8. Kaplan, J. (2020, March 31). Hospitals have left many COVID-19 patients who don’t speak English alone, confused and without proper care. ProPublica. https://www.propublica.org/article/hospitals-have-left-many-covid19-patients-who-dont-speak-english-alone-confused-and-without-proper-care?token=jg6nGk6aRoymOqJmDTSthj1PIBKaGEW9
  9. Ortega, P., Shin, T. M., Pérez-Cordón, C., & Martínez, G. A. (2020). Virtual medical Spanish education at the corazón of Hispanic/Latinx health During COVID-19. Medical Science Educator, 30(4), 1661–1666. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40670-020-01058-0
  10.  National Health Law Program. (2021, April 30). Civil rights complaint filed over discriminatory provision of COVID-19 services to persons with limited English proficiency. https://healthlaw.org/news/civil-rights-complaint-filed-over-discriminatory-provision-of-covid-19-services-to-persons-with-limited-english-proficiency/
  11. National Health Law Program. (2021, April 30). Civil rights complaint filed over discriminatory provision of COVID-19 services to persons with limited English proficiency. https://healthlaw.org/news/civil-rights-complaint-filed-over-discriminatory-provision-of-covid-19-services-to-persons-with-limited-english-proficiency/
  12. Vela, M. B., Fritz, C., Press, V. G., & Girotti, J. (2016). Medical students’ experiences and perspectives on interpreting for LEP patients at two US medical schools. Journal of Racial and Ethnic Health Disparities, 3, 245–249. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40615-015-0134-7
  13. Diamond, L., Izquierdo, K., Canfield, D., Matsoukas, K., & Gany, F. (2019). A systematic review of the impact of patient–physician non-English language concordance on quality of care and outcomes. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 34, 1591–1606. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11606-019-04847-5
  14. Diamond, L., Izquierdo, K., Canfield, D., Matsoukas, K., & Gany, F. (2019). A systematic review of the impact of patient–physician non-English language concordance on quality of care and outcomes. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 34, 1591–1606. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11606-019-04847-5
  15. Ortega, P., Shin, T. M., Pérez-Cordón, C., & Martínez, G. A. (2020). Virtual medical Spanish education at the corazón of Hispanic/Latinx health During COVID-19. Medical Science Educator, 30(4), 1661–1666. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40670-020-01058-0
  16. Ortega, P. (2018). Spanish language concordance in U.S. medical care: A multifaceted challenge and call to action. Academic Medicine, 93(9), 1276–1280. https://doi.org/10.1097/ACM.0000000000002307

Tags from the story

Coronavirus

COVID-19

COVID-19 Pandemic

health care acess

health care inequities

Interpretation

linguistic discrimination

Recent Comments

Jonathan Ornelaz

Hello Samantha, I think you article does show the slowness of the medical health care system to get more inline with the times, and to not have the foresight to see what was coming around the corner with languages issues in hospitals and urgent care. We all realize that this country is a melting pot and that we have more people coming here to live then in their own home countries, as such the medical facilities need to adapt and have ways to communicate with all different types of languages. Even if that means once the hospitals hire someone that somehow they are sent to language trainings of at 2 types of different languages, just in case you might be in a situation where you can help translate. I think your article shines a light on the missteps of alot of companies and services that are falling short, because they have people come in who do not speak English as their first language and need help and do not have a way to know what is going on sometimes or where to go when they need assistance.

reply

22/08/2021

11:14 am

Nydia Ramirez

I loved the statistics displayed throughout the article. This hits close to home because I can relate to many things in this article. There was a light shone on racial health disparities especially with minorities. Being from Brownsville, Texas in the Valley, many people I knew were uneducated or did not have the right resources to get vaccinated for Covid 19. Many were scared to go to big cities because of the language barrier. It is sad to see many people lose their lives or get misinformed due to this. There should be a surplus in hiring Bilingual doctors because it could save many peoples, particularly minorites, lives.

reply

23/08/2021

11:14 am

Phoebe D-L

This is such an incredibly important article as it touches on an issue I would imagine many English-speakers never consider. For a country with no official language, the intentional difficulties faced by people who speak a language other than English are numerous. Hopefully with more awareness raised, we can one day provide accessible medical care for anyone who needs it.

reply

02/09/2021

11:14 am

Morgan Kuchta

Your article and these anecdotes shed very necessary light on the issues within health care. It is so unfortunate to see such language barriers continuing to exist, especially in such serious cases. Not only does each patient deserve meaningful access to health care in a language they understand, but, just as Priscilla Huang said, they have a right to it. The importance of language access and health equity is absolutely not lost on me. Thank you for such an important article!

reply

21/09/2021

11:14 am

Brittney Carden

The US healthcare system is one that has a variety of major problems, but I think the pandemic has highlighted just how poor our system is. It breaks my heart to think of the people who have been affected by this problem, the fact that the language barrier still exists in the US is unfortunate, to say the least. Thank you for shedding light on a topic that needs to be in more discussions.

reply

03/10/2021

11:14 am

Christopher Metta Bexar

I have to play devil’s advocate here. What this article is trying to point out is the failure of the secondary schools and the Hispanic community to teach English. I have worked in professions which require the clients to learn to speak English to access them, and the clients assume it’ s the responsibility of the provider to translate and not theirs to learn to speak English. Scaffolding has been in k-12 schools for three decades and still most Latinos still want translators. This shows either a failure in the schools or an unwillingness among Latinos to learn. I understand the need to provide services but those dollars should go into necessary services not multi lingual translation. I would not expect to have Japanese doctors cater to my lack of Japanese if I were ill in Tokyo.

reply

07/10/2021

11:14 am

Trenton Boudreaux

A very interesting article on a problem in our healthcare that I hadn’t thought of much. It’s depressing how the reason behind the Latino/Latina community being the second highest COVID infection rate is due to poor communication. It’s especially tragic given how hard of a language English is to learn. In either case, I hope that, with the improvement in translation services, better health care can be provided to those who can’t speak English.

reply

18/10/2021

11:14 am

Kimberly Rivera

Incredible article. I appreciate the fact that you went over one of the key issues in America’s health system. While it is needed for all job fields to have bilingual workers in case someone of a different racial background and language needs help, I would also like to point out that the awareness needs to come from both sides. While America does need to work on the communication skills and translators for other languages, it is also needed to help others learn English.

reply

30/10/2021

11:14 am

Amanda Uribe

Great article Sam! Before reading this, I had never thought about the problem between languages in healthcare. It is horrible that lives could have been saved but a language barrier prevented information sharing. I like how you addressed btoh the institutions of health care and the workers themselves. The change starts with medical professionals speaking up to provide services that help patients communicate with their doctors. I hope we are able to adapt to the needs of our country in health care.

reply

13/02/2022

11:14 am

Elizabeth Hernandez

Samantha, this was so good! When I shadowed at a doctor’s office in Laredo, TX, there was this nurse practitioner that didn’t know a lick of Spanish. It was really hard to see patients and their parents trying to explain what was wrong in their native language, and her not being able to understand it. I was later given permission to translate for them, but this was my first hand experience with a language barrier possibly preventing people whose native language is one other than English from getting proper healthcare. There is not always someone who is bilingual to intervene. Great article!

reply

13/02/2022

11:14 am

Leave a Reply