StMU Research Scholars

Featuring Scholarly Research, Writing, and Media at St. Mary’s University

April 28, 2017

The Fall of the Russian Imperial Family & Its Lost Princess Anastasia

The youngest daughter of Alexandra and Nicholas II, the last tsar of Russia, was born in 1901 near St. Petersburg, Russia. Anastasia Nikolaevna Romanov, along with her three older sisters and one younger brother, were heirs to the throne that they believed would continue to rule Russia indefinitely.1 However, the Romanov dynasty–after ruling from 1547 to 1919–came to a gruesome and abrupt end when the family was executed during the Russian Revolution by the Bolsheviks. But because there was no proof of Anastasia’s death among the graves, the public has ever since been fascinated by her possible mysterious disappearance. She has since become the story line for books, movies, and even plays. Over time, the lost Princess of Russia has become a significant cultural figure in Russian history.

The Romanov family. Anastasia is the young girl sitting to the far left, next to her father Nicholas II | Courtesy of Beautifulrus

This most fabled of the Romanovs was named Anastasia, meaning “the breaker of chains,” because Nicholas II had pardoned a group of students that had rebelled in St. Petersburg the year she was born. The Tsar was disappointed that his wife had birthed yet another daughter and not yet a son to take the throne. When Alexandra did finally give birth an heir, he was born with an extreme case of hemophilia and was not expected to live beyond his childhood. It was said that the pressure of birthing an heir affected the Tsarina during her pregnancies, and for this reason the children suffered from illnesses; for Anastasia’s part, sh had a foot disorder and back weakness.2 Despite her poor health, Anastasia was a lively and charismatic child, who was nicknamed the “Imp” and “Sunshine” since she would spend her days playing with her siblings or pulling pranks on her family or servants.3 She climbed trees, played with animals, and like any other child, would cause chaos. Except she was not like any other child; she was a Romanov. Anastasia was part of the longest Russian dynasty to ever rule; at the end of the day, she was royalty.

The young princess Anastasia would spend her time reading, studying, running around, and practicing her stitching | Courtesy of Russiapedia.

Despite their riches and huge palaces, the Tsar and Tsarina did not spoil their children or give way to an affluent lifestyle. The princess and prince shared rooms and had a strict, fixed schedule that included cold showers, breakfast, tutoring (in languages, grammar, geography, Bible studies) and then dinner. Although the young princess was described as being outgoing, social, and sometimes even a trouble maker, she never spent time with outsiders because her interactions were limited to the people who lived with her.4 Forbidden from leaving the grounds, Anastasia and her siblings lived almost as prisoners in their wealthy, quiet, and stern homes. There was, however, one person that Anastasia viewed as a close and intimate friend: Gregory Rasputin.

The picture shows Rasputin and the prince Alexei spending time together | Courtesy of Pinterest

After using some of his alleged healing powers on the sickly prince Alexei, the Romanov family took in this strange, holy man from Siberia. Rasputin quickly gained the trust of the Romanov family and would use his influence to attack enemies in the government and move up the social ladder. The family’s close relationship with Rasputin was criticized strongly by many, whispering that he had seduced the Tsarina Alexandra and the young princesses, including Anastasia.5.

The mystic man Gregory Rasputin | Courtesy of Russiapedia

The family’s close bond with this mystic man discredited the authority of the Tsar and increased the public’s resentment towards Nicolas II, who had proven his lack of leadership when Russia was defeated in the war with Japan in 1905. After this, the people of Russia demanded civil liberties and an end to the war, but the authorities responded by opening fire on these peaceful protests, a day known as Bloody Sunday.6 In an attempt to reconcile with the public, the tsar granted the people a house of parliament, named the Duma, and a constitution, but he nullified and ignored both, and so tensions escalated. Then in 1914, when World War I broke out, the tsar left Empress Alexandra and her right man, Rasputin, in charge of the government while he commanded the Russian army on the battlefield. This decision allowed Rasputin to abuse his authority and, in 1916, Russian generals and other  relations to the royal family had had enough and assassinated him. World War I resulted in a high number of Russian casualties, a blow to the economy, and social instability that resulted from a lack of resources such as food. In these times of chaos, the people blamed the royal family for involving Russia in this bloodbath; so they, along with the Tsar’s generals, demanded that the Romanov’s give up the throne and hand power over to a provisional government, the first Revolution of 1917.7

Lenin  addresses soldiers of the new Soviet Army in Red Square in Moscow on May 25, 1919 | Courtesy of Daily Mail

This unstable, temporary government lasted only until it was overthrown by Vladimir Lenin and the Bolsheviks, the second Revolution of 1917. The Bolsheviks moved to create soviet rule after the Russian Revolution. It was Lenin who decided to place the Romanov family under house arrest in Ekaterinburg in the Ural Mountains. The family was heavily guarded, given limited portions, and treated like traitors to the Soviets. Despite the unfortunate conditions that the Romanov’s faced, Anastasia, who was by this time seventeen years old, refused to let the Russian Revolution and the Bolsheviks break her spirit. She would sing, joke, and pull pranks while her father would read books, all in an attempt to lighten the somber mood. While they were under house arrest, the family sewed jewelry into their clothing in the event that they could escape the house and flee. However, before Anastasia and her family could even attempt their escape, Lenin ordered the execution of the Romanovs in 1918.8.

The Romanovs were held as prisoners in this house in Ekaterinburg by the Ural Mountains | Courtesy of Teaattrianon

The guards and a squad of Bolsheviks led the family into the cellar in the house of Ekaterinburg, where after being read their death sentence, were brutally shot. The men hesitated shooting Anastasia and her siblings because they were children, so most of the gunfire was directed at Nicolas II and Alexandra. However, the orders were to kill, and after the first round, most of the family was still alive due to the bulletproof undergarments they had sowed with their jewelry. Sadly, no type of jewel could have saved the family from being cruelly stabbed to death in a cold, dark cellar. No member of the Romanov family survived that night. The myth that Anastasia and her brother had survived the executions was created when word spread that two members of the family woke up as their bodies were carried out of the cellar. Unfortunately, they didn’t escape, instead they were stabbed to death, driven out into the forest, burned, and their ashes scattered.9

The most famous impersonator of Anastasia, Anna Anderson was not proven wrong until after her death | Picture by Express

The Bolsheviks tried to conceal the brutal death of the Romanovs to avoid any type of opposition to their new rule. But soon after, the world learned about the horrid events that occurred in Ekateringburg.10 It was the tragic end of the royal family and the innocence of the young Princess Anastasia that inspired the people of Russia to hope that she was still alive. Rumors that Anastasia had survived spread like wildfire in Russia, Germany, and all over the world, including to the United States. The people’s undying hope and the lack of evidence of Anastasia’s death, gave way to impersonators who claimed they were the rightful Anastasia and deserved her inheritance and fame. These false claims were for the most part brushed aside, until Anna Anderson woke up in a hospital in Berlin after a suicide attempt and claimed to be part of the Romanov family.11 From the 1920’s and until her death in 1984, this Polish woman tried to convince the world that she was indeed Anastasia. Some distant relatives of the Romanovs believed her, although others, like a close aunt, Olga Romanov, did not and called her a stranger. In 1970 Dr. Alexander Avdonin discovered the grave that contained five of the seven members of the Romanov family, but kept it a secret until the fall of the Soviet Union in 1991. The DNA was examined for years, but it was not until 2007 that Anastasia’s remains were found and her death was then confirmed to have happened on the day of the execution.12

In 1997, Walt Disney released the film Anastasia. In this story, the lost princess falls in love and finds her way back home | Courtesy of Beautifulrus

The tragic and heart breaking story of Princess Anastasia and the fallen Romanov family was romanticized into books, plays, and movies. For example, the popular film “Anastasia” was produced in the 50’s,  the musical “Anya” was a success on Broadway in the 1960’s, and even in 1997, Walt Disney released an animated film about Anastasia–who fights against a demonic Rasputin in order to recover her identity.13 Although entertaining, these movies and plays do not convey the true, gruesome, and unfair story of Anastasia. Instead, they do a good job of creating a fantasy that guarantees a happy ending to the myth. Sometimes it is easier to hope for happy endings and fairy tales than to open our eyes to the harsh reality of life, as was the case with the life of Princess Anastasia.

To this day, there are those who doubt the authenticity of the DNA results and believe that Anastasia did manage to escape. The Russian Orthodox church has proposed to grant Anastasia sainthood in order to honor the Romanov family and the great Tsars that once ruled Russia, but others believe that they should remain buried in the past.14 Whatever the case may be, there is no denying that Anastasia is a symbol of the power behind royal families, an icon of Russian history, a romantic fairy tale, and a tragic ending that will continue to live on.

  1.  Encyclopedia of World Biography, 2004, s.v. “Anastasia Nicholaievna Romanov.”
  2. Nancy Bilyeau, “Will the Real Anastasia Romanov Please Stand Up?” Town & Country, April 25, 2017.
  3. Kyle Smith, Craig Mellow, Ron Arias, and Elizabeth Leonard, “Tragic Child,” People 49, No. 1, (January 12, 1998), 67.
  4. Kyle Smith, Craig Mellow, Ron Arias, and Elizabeth Leonard, “Tragic Child,” People 49, No. 1, (January 12, 1998), 67.
  5. John B. Saul, “In ‘Rasputin,’ Author Examines the Truth behind the Downfall of the Romanovs,” The Seattle Times, November 5, 2016
  6. Bryan Brown, “The Last Czar Nicholas II: The Heir of Russia’s Once Powerful Romanov Dynasty Fell Victim to Bad Decisions, Bad Luck, and the Tide of History,” Junior Scholastic 14, no. 1 (2005): 14.
  7. Bryan Brown, “The Last Czar Nicholas II: The Heir of Russia’s Once Powerful Romanov Dynasty Fell Victim to Bad Decisions, Bad Luck, and the Tide of History,” Junior Scholastic 14, no. 1 (2005): 14.
  8. Yuri Zarakhovich, “Playing Politics with the Romanovs,” Time, August 26, 2007
  9. Simon Sebag Montefiore, “Goodnight, Sweet Romanov,” Town & Country 170, no. 5430 (November 2016), 162.
  10. Yuri Zarakhovich, “Playing Politics with the Romanovs.” Time, August 26, 2007.
  11. Sarah Appleton, “Found?” New Moon Girls 16, no. 4 (April 3, 2009): 20.
  12. Michael D. Coble and Odile M. Loreille, “Mystery Solved: The Identification of the Two Missing Romanov Children Using DNA Analysis,” PLoS ONE 4, no. 3 (March 2009): 1–9.
  13. Nancy Bilyeau, “Will the Real Anastasia Romanov Please Stand Up?” Town & Country, April 25, 2017.
  14. Kyle Smith, Craig Mellow, Ron Arias, and Elizabeth Leonard, “Tragic Child,” People 49, No. 1, (January 12, 1998), 67.

Tags from the story

Anastasia Nikolaevna Romanov

Russian Revolution

Tsar Nicolas II

Recent Comments

Christine Sackey

I had no idea how tragically the real-life princess’s life ended up being. I believe that putting Rasputin and Empress Alexandra in charge of the government was a mistake. This just aggravated the citizens and allowed a more open door for people to talk about the royal family in a bad light. It is crazy to think that one man, Vladimir Lenin, could order demands to take a whole family life away. Through all the hardship, Princess Anastasia was still positive and joyful. This type of spirit is admirable considering the conditions that she was living in. I also thought that the family was very smart to create those bullet proof clothes out of jewelry and clothes. I secretly still hope that Anastasia could have escaped, but recent DNA results confirmed that she did die on that day. Though she might have died that day her spirit still lives on today.

reply

23/08/2017

5:06 pm

Sarah Mares

The story of the fallen Romanov family and Princess Anastasia’s whereabouts is always one that interests me. As a kid, I absolutely loved watching the 1997 Disney portrayal of Anastasia, her family and her rumored disappearance. Since then, I have continued the read up on the actual tragic events of the family and Anastasia. The people of Russia were uncomfortable with the relationship between Rasputin and the Romanov family, which was a great instinct on their part, as he took advantage of his given-power and authority when left in charge. What the Bolsheviks did to the Romanov family was extremely tragic, but the rumors of Anastasia’s escape was a primary source of hope for the people of Russia at the time.

reply

23/08/2017

5:06 pm

Samman Tyata

I found this article really interesting and informative. Apart from that, the article provides a brief detail about the history of the Romanov dynasty. To be honest, while reading the article, I was still expecting Anastasia to be alive. It was very upsetting to read that all of the them were brutally killed. I am happy to know that many books, plays and movies today are made depicting her. To sum it up, it was a good read.

reply

23/08/2017

5:06 pm

Josemaria Soriano

I consider myself a lover of history, and among all world histories, my favorite undoubtedly is the History of Russia. Russia is a country full of mysteries and a completely unique culture, and from an early age I have read a lot about the history of Imperial Russia, Soviet Russia (USSR) and the now Russian Federation. That is why I have read this article with much rejoicing, and also with a very critical eye, since I humbly consider that I handle this topic. It seems to me that both the cinema and the musicals have given a very romantic vision not only of Anastasia, but of the Romanovs. The sad truth is that the government of the Tsars was a completely cruel government. While the people literally starved to death, the Tsars spent money on parties, palaces and amusements. They did not allocate money for the poor, and sent their hungry people to fight against Japan and in the First World War. It was then that the Revolution of February 1917 occurs, where really all sectors of Russia, from the bakers to the military of the Tsar, went to take the Winter Palace. The Mensheviks, led by Alexander Kerensky, allied themselves with the Russian aristocracy and kept Russia in the Great War. They did not make any changes to feed the people, and they shot the protesters. Finally, the Bolsheviks in the October Revolution, led by Leon Trotsky (Lenin was in exile, he did not remove Kerensky), took the Winter Palace at night. At that moment the civil war between Mensheviks and Bolsheviks began. The Mensheviks were desperately seeking to the royal family, in order to return the Tsar’s government. Lenin, upon hearing of the Menshevik plans, ordered the murder of the entire royal family. It is very sad that innocent children had to pay for the mistakes of their parents. The story of Anastasia is a truly moving story. I congratulate the writer for such a good criteria when choosing her article topic. I hope to read more articles on Russian history, my favorite one.

reply

30/08/2017

5:06 pm

Rafael Azuaje

Why did it take so long for Princess Anastasia’s remains to be found? How can people become so compelled by political beliefs that they will murder children? I think about the current political situation here in the US and question it. Will Americans involved in the extreme ends of the political spectrum reach that point? I certainly hope not. The story of Princess Anastasia is truly a fascinating one.

reply

30/08/2017

5:06 pm

Abigale Carney

This was a very interesting article! I never knew that the Disney movie Anastasia was based on a true story. It is so sad that her family was brutally murdered, now I understand the movie when it was filled with ghosts. The movie always intrigued me because Anastasia never found her family. It is so sad that Anastasia did not survive these murders like she did in the movie, I believe that she was the Russians last bit of hope when there were rumors of her escape.

reply

30/08/2017

5:06 pm

Blanca Martinez

This article holds many details I had no idea about, then again I only saw the Disney movie rather than read any historical facts about Princess Anastasia. It actually is very sad that Anastasia did die on the day all her family was killed rather than survive in another area. Also the fact that someone could actually play her role and distant family agreeing although the lady was Polish is kind of not very smart on their part. Thankfully her aunt recognized that the impersonator wasn’t her. If only she had survived maybe their history could have been different.

reply

31/08/2017

5:06 pm

Teresa Valdez

One of the reasons I fell in love with history is the story of Anastasia. I remember being a extremely heartbroken ten year old who refused to watch her favorite princess movie once she read a biographical book on the Romanov grand duchess. That being said, this article brings such life to the character of Anastasia by giving insights to her childhood mischievousness. I had no idea the extent of power that that Rasputin was given during the reign. With political advisors abusing their power like this, it is easy to see why the peasants revolted. Still, this is no excuse for the brutal murders of the children. Great article!

reply

01/09/2017

5:06 pm

Josselyn Arrieta-Meraz

There’s a story behind every person, every individual carries one. Learning about this royal family and their misfortune happenings really makes you think of how messed up the world was, the different views had so much influence that people were judged by every one of them. Anastasia was a girl along with her siblings they were young, they had no fault over the actions of their parents. Like described in the article, she was a child who loved playing pranks and games, like any kid her age. The fact that after everyone found out about the tragic ending of the royal family the felt bad. With pity and regret they had that sense of hope that surrounded them all. Anastasia would could have lived but instead she is a name in children’s movies where in them there is always a happy ending unlike the one Anastasia had.

reply

01/09/2017

5:06 pm

Karla Chavana

The lost princess of Russia, Anastasia is such an intriguing story. The article makes wonderful constructive facts of the actual history, of Anastasia’s life. I too, like many only knew of the princess due to the Disney Movie. As a child, I remember feeling sad and confused by the portrayal of some of the characters (of course they were dead!). This article allowed me to make connections, and not only analyze the story told by the world of Disney, but discover the reality of the events.

reply

06/09/2017

5:06 pm

1 2 3

Leave a Reply