StMU Research Scholars

Featuring Scholarly Research, Writing, and Media at St. Mary’s University

November 2, 2016

The Assassination of Julius Caesar: Tyrannicide or Treason?

Twenty three stab wounds was all it took to take down one of the most powerful leaders in Roman history. Despite being hailed as a powerful war hero in history, Julius Caesar was murdered in his own city by his own people on the Ides of March 44 B.C.E.1 Gaius Julius Caesar was born on July 13, 100 B.C.E. in Rome, and became dictator of the Roman Republic in October 49 B.C.E. The powerful image of Caesar even today cannot be compared, and that is why his legacy is still alive today. He was an ambitious figure that conquered modern day France, led the civil war, and influenced the fall of the Roman Republic. The Roman Republic before its fall served the wealthy and the privileged.2 Caesar did not want to do away with the Republic despite what critics say; all he wanted to do was reform it and give more power to the people. Members in the Senate, however, would not allow this. Julius Caesar’s assassination cannot be justified; it was treason and murder, even though those who murdered him defended their actions as tyrannicide.

Exhibition at the Grand Palais. Original statue dated back to 50-40 B.C.E. Courtesy of WikiCommons.
Bust of Julius Caesar | Exhibition at the Grand Palais | Dated to 50-40 B.C.E. | Courtesy of Wikimedia Commons

The conspirators were not from outside forces of Rome; instead, they were from Caesar’s inner circle of elite senators. Caesar entrusted Brutus and Cassius to be his eyes and ears in the Senate, but they did just the opposite. Brutus, who was pardoned by Caesar after helping Caesar’s foe Pompey during the recent civil war, was one of the masterminds behind the assassination. In 44, Caesar appointed Brutus as proprietor of Gaul, or modern day France, which was one of the highest offices a nobleman could hold.3 Cassius, another conspirator who had been pardoned by Caesar at the beginning of his dictatorship, was also one of the masterminds behind the assassination. Repeatedly, Caesar seems to have contributed to his own death by pardoning those who did not deserve to be pardoned. Instead of dealing harshly with his enemies, he pardoned them and kept them close. He took the saying keep your enemies close to an extreme, since they ended up close enough to assassinate him.

In some ways, the conspirators who plotted against Caesar’s life had a clear justifiable reason in mind. The conspirators defied Caesar’s authority and perceived him to be a popular leader who threatened their privileged interests. They truly believed they were saving the Republic. They wanted to restore republican liberties that Caesar had robbed from them.4 For example, Caesar completely disregarded their unwritten constitution and the Roman mos maiorum, or ancestral customs, when he appointed commoners to offices that only aristocrats could hold. He was defying their unspoken and unwritten rule that commoners cannot be placed in charge.5 Doing away with Caesar would do good to the people of Rome; therefore, tyrannicide was justifiable in their eyes. And so their treasonous act will forever be remembered as the most infamous assassination in history.

An oil on canvas painting depicting the murder of Julius Caesar by Karl von Piloty in 1865. Courtesy of WikiCommons.
An oil on canvas painting depicting the murder of Julius Caesar by Karl von Piloty in 1865 | Courtesy of Wikimedia Commons

Although some of his actions were faulty, Caesar did not deserve to die in the treacherous way that he did. Murder consists of three things and the conspirators held all three of them, which is intent, malice, and premeditation. The conspirators intended to kill Caesar before he left for Parthia on March 18, 44 B.C.E.6 The raid on Parthia would cause Caesar to be away for months on end, so the conspirators had to act quickly. They premeditated their attack before Caesar left by taking into account time, numbers, and politics. They knew Caesar would be unaccompanied and surrounded by Senate members such as themselves. They also knew that only Senate members were allowed inside the Senate chambers, prohibiting any outsiders Caesar usually surrounded himself with.7 Their malice was proven in the gruesome way Caesar was left on the steps of the Senate building. Together, they marched to the Senate, with daggers under their white togas, with intent, malice, and premeditation to kill Julius Caesar. Before Caesar’s assassination, every senator had to sign an oath in which they promised to maintain Caesar’s safety. The penalty for violating the oath was the death penalty.8  The Senators involved almost got away with murder, but Octavian, Caesar’s nephew and successor, and Marc Antony, Caesar’s best friend, hunted the assassins down one by one and avenged his murder.

 

  1. Encyclopedia Britannica, 2015, s.v. “Julius Caesar,” by Arnold Joseph Toynbee.
  2. Michael Parenti, The Assassination Of Julius Caesar: A People’s History Of Ancient Rome (New York: The New Press, 2004), 47.
  3.  Encyclopedia Britannica, 2015, s.v. “Marcus Junius Brutus,” by E. Badian.
  4. Parenti, The Assassination Of Julius Caesar: A People’s History Of Ancient Rome, 2.
  5. Parenti, The Assassination Of Julius Caesar: A People’s History Of Ancient Rome, 3.
  6. Barry Strauss, The Death of Caesar: The Story of History’s Most Famous Assassination (New York: Simon & Schuster, 2016), 54.
  7. Greg Woolf, “Et Tu Brute? : Caesar’s Murder and Political Assassination” (London: Profile Books, 2006), 45.
  8. Strauss, The Death of Caesar: The Story of History’s Most Famous Assassination, 51.

Tags from the story

Julius Caesar

Recent Comments

Mehmet Samuk

Very good choice of topic and well-written article. I am sure everybody heard the assassination of the Julius Ceasar but I never really read an article and learned the real facts behind it. I enjoyed reading your article.

reply

02/11/2016

6:47 am

Christopher Repka

This is an interesting article. I didn’t know that Julius Caesar appointed commoners to his cabinet. It would be interesting to know Caesar’s reasoning for doing so.

reply

02/11/2016

6:47 am

Analina Devora

Very well researched article. This topic may have been difficult to write about trying to find facts people didn’t already know about. This is a very famous topic and I think almost everyone has heard the story. However, you did a great job of informing readers of new facts. I didn’t know that Caesar completely disregarded their unwritten constitution. Well done!

reply

02/11/2016

6:47 am

Kassandra Guillen

This is a very well written and well researched article. It is quite a shame that those he kept closest to him were the ones to deceive him in the worst way possible by murdering him. I have always been aware of this story, but have never been given such great facts and details of this event. Job well done!

reply

02/11/2016

6:47 am

Vanessa Carrillo

This was a good article, I remember reading about Julius Caesar in high school. I remember that he was an interesting person, although some didn’t understand him, he had a good idea.

reply

03/11/2016

6:47 am

Jocelyn Alvarez Bibian

Great job at describing the intentions of those who assassinated Caesar. This was a very well written article. I can see both perspectives; in one hand, these people, Brutus and Cassius, tried to protect the republic of Rome and were willing to defend their interest until the point of killing one of the most powerful Roman rulers. On the other hand are Caesar’s intentions in removing the republic. It seems that he wanted to give all people of Rome more opportunity to succeed. It may be a mistake from Caesar’s part to pardon these men, and I do agree with you about him taking a great risk by having his enemies close. Definitely, this assassination has been a topic of interest for years, and it will continue to be. Congratulations on this article. Great job!

reply

05/11/2016

6:47 am

Andres Palacios

Very well researched and written article, interesting how in one of the countries where democracy was predominant, 23 members of the senate instead of taking a stand in the senate they decided to murder Julius Caesar.

reply

07/11/2016

6:47 am

Victoria Sanchez

This article is very-well researched and excellently written. I think you did a great job about delving further into such a difficult topic by including facts and anecdotes surrounding Caesar’s assassination that people may not have learned in high school. The organization of the article is great. I like how you opened with a general idea of the assassination and your opinion on the topic, then went into to explaining the two sides of the argument, and finally showing evidence to support the claim that Caesar’s murder was unjust. I agree with your claim, and you provided a good and well-supported argument. Great job!

reply

15/11/2016

6:47 am

1 2 3

Leave a Reply