StMU Research Scholars

Featuring Scholarly Research, Writing, and Media at St. Mary’s University

September 23, 2018

Dorothea Lange: Pictures Are Worth A Thousand Words

What can a single image possibly say about our complex world? Of course, one picture can’t possibly capture everything. All of the tragedy and despair or all of the celebrations and joyful moments can hardly be captured in a million pictures. So, what difference can one picture really make? Documentary photographer, Dorothea Lange, set out with a simple goal in mind: to document the lives of the ordinary people in the world around her. In doing so, she inadvertently brought about drastic change through the increase of awareness of poverty and the conditions people were forced to endure. Lange influenced millions through the use of one single picture, and, that influence has and will continue for decades in the future.1

Lange found her life’s work and passion as a photographer in the 1930s, following the path of a common photographer in capturing people’s portraits and selling them to make a profit. While she enjoyed her work and was obviously very skilled, she always thought of herself as more of a historian than a true artist. As her career in portraiture continued, she improved her skills and came to open up a studio of her own in San Francisco, California. Here, she continued to perfect her craft, and she shared her talent with those among the wealthier classes of her society. It didn’t take long, however, for her to realize that her picture-taking skills could be used for much bigger, much greater, and overall, much more important things.2

In the midst of her successful portrait-focused career, the Great Depression struck and ravaged the lives of Americans far and wide. Lange, who originally, “would have thought it enough to take a picture of a man, nothing more,” quickly came to readjust her mindset upon seeing the pain in the world around her, and instead, decided that she “wanted to take a picture of a man as he stood in the world.”3 In 1933, a time in American history categorized by increasing tension and unbearable poverty in the lives of the average worker, Lange made what would come to be a life-changing decision: a drastic change in her creative mindset from elegant portraits to exposing the conditions of poverty. This single change in her life led her to become, undoubtedly, one of the most influential documentary photographers of the Great Depression.4

This young mother of two children, and her husband both worked for 5 hours picking peas in California only to earn $2.25 to support their family│Courtesy of wikipedia.org

In May of 1935, with her newfound purpose of documenting the suffering around her, Lange became an employee of the Resettlement Administration (RA), later known as the Farm Security Administration (FSA). The goal of the RA was to bring to light the struggles of rural poverty in the country through the use of photographs. They found that sharing the conditions and hardships of life through photographs was much more impactful than any written reports, because the audience could see situations with their own eyes, which they may not have ever had the chance to see. The RA used this method of documentary photography because they recognized how powerful it could be and they needed to gain support for their projects. Lange’s job with the RA was demanding and required her to travel across the country to places that many had never heard of or even knew existed at all.5 Needless to say, she completed meaningful work and had many adventures throughout her time with the RA.

Lange captured the struggles of the Great Depression in the faces of the people around her, like this homeless young woman, carrying the youngest of her seven children, traveling from Phoenix to San Diego in search of relief │Courtesy of wikipedia.org

On one such adventure, on a rainy day in March of 1936, Lange had just finished another one of her photography excursions in California, and had packed up all of her equipment and supplies to begin her more than seven-hour drive home to her family. The drive started off dull and uneventful as she pushed ahead in the pouring rain. Occasionally, there were other cars and signs on the side of the road, but nothing out of the ordinary for the small San Luis Obispo County road. “PEA-PICKERS CAMP” one sign read. She considered stopping, thinking she would document more of the harsh conditions in the rural area, but instead, decided against it, knowing she still had a long trip ahead of her. While the sign and the camp became further and further behind her, they never left the forefront of her mind.

As she drove on, she thought to herself, questioning what could have been so special about that camp. It was just another pea-pickers camp, like the others she had already seen and taken pictures of. Why should she care about another one? It couldn’t possibly be that different from the ones she’d already seen. She would probably just drive in to find the same suffering and poverty she’d seen at the others. What difference would it make if she just drove past this one camp? Nobody even knew it existed anyway, so it wouldn’t make a difference, right? After getting lost in this inner argument, trying in every way possible to convince herself why she should not turn around, Lange almost unconsciously made a U-turn twenty miles past the sign and began to drive back to the camp.6

Upon reaching the camp that she had almost convinced herself to leave behind, Lange was drawn to one woman in particular. She didn’t ask for the woman’s name, or anything about her history or how she came to work at the pea-picker camp. Lange simply saw this kind of information as irrelevant to achieving her goal, which was to highlight the horrendous conditions and intense poverty of the Great Depression. While she didn’t learn much about the woman, she did learn that she was a mother of seven, living in a makeshift tent surviving mostly on frozen vegetables and small birds. The woman and Lange talked briefly, and then Lange proceeded to take a total of five pictures of the mother and several of her children, later saying, “There she sat in that lean-to tent with her children huddled around her, and seemed to know that my pictures might help her, and so she helped me. There was a sort of equality about it.” After spending a brief ten minutes at the camp, with the limited amount of information Lange had on her subjects, and a grand total of five pictures, Lange once again packed up her supplies and continued on her long trip back home.7

Taken in March of 1936, this image displays the makeshift home of the Migrant Mother and her seven children on the pea-picking farm in Nipomo, California │Courtesy of wikipedia.org

Lange’s intuition to turn her car around that day must have been very powerful. Deep down inside she must have known that her choice to go on or to turn around would make a profound difference in her story and in the lives of millions of those struggling around the world. That one, ten minute stop and those five pictures that Lange almost didn’t get the chance to take, later came to shape her entire career. Those pictures are the reason she is remembered to this day, the most famous being titled “Migrant Mother.” This image depicts the mother of seven that Lange met at the pea-picker camp, staring far off into the distance, seemingly lost in thought and isolated, even as she was surrounded by several of her children. Most, if not all, of Lange’s pictures had a recurring theme of separation from society, with an emphasis on the struggling classes and the pain that they had to endure on a daily basis.8 Lange’s “Migrant Mother,” however, displayed this theme so well that it became a symbol of the Great Depression as a whole. The image became an icon of the Great Depression and people in different cultures even began to replicate it to make it relevant to themselves. One picture gave the mother and children Spanish features, while still another gave them black features.9 Her work was so moving that it mirrored the isolated feelings of numerous cultures and became universally accepted and used to try and changed the way these people were being treated. Lange’s “Migrant Mother” slowly became one of the most recognizable and copied images in history.10

  1. Encyclopedia of the Great Depression, 2004, s.v. “Lange, Dorothea,” by Linda Gordon.
  2. Allison McNeill et al., Great Depression and New Deal Biographies (Great Depression and the New Deal Reference Library: vol. 2: Biographies, UXL, 2003), 141-142.
  3. David P. Peeler, Hope among Us Yet: Social Criticism and Social Solace in Depression America (Athens, Georgia: University of Georgia Press, 1987), 62.
  4. Encyclopedia of the Great Depression, 2004, s.v. “Lange, Dorothea,” by Ed. Robert S. McElvaine.
  5. Allison McNeill et al., Great Depression and New Deal Biographies, (Great Depression and the New Deal Reference Library: vol. 2: Biographies, UXL, 2003), 144-146.
  6. Milton Meltzer, Dorothea Lange: A Photographer’s Life (New York, NY: Farrat, Straus & Giroux, 1978), 132-133.
  7. Dorothea Lange, “The Assignment I’ll Never Forget: Migrant Mother,” Popular Photography February 1960, 1-2.
  8. Melissa A. McEuen, Seeing America: Women Photographers between the Wars (Kentucky: The University Press of Kentucky, 2000), 110.
  9. Judith Fryer Davidov, Women’s Camera Work: Self/Body/Other in American Visual Culture. (Durham, North Carolina: Duke University Press, 1998), 5-6.
  10. Lawrence W. Levine, “The Historian and the Icon: Photography and the History of the American People in the 1930s and 1940s,” In Documenting America, 1935–1943, (Berkley: University of California Press, 1988), 16.

Tags from the story

“Migrant Mother”

Dorothea Lange

Photography

The Great Depression

Recent Comments

Robert Freise

The pictures that represents the article represents the negative emotions and struggles of the great depression. The images conveyed so many different issues at hand. She was just trying to help her kids and all she wanted was to help her kids during that great time of need. This article gave me a bigger sense on how the troubles of the great depression in the 30’s and 40’s had an extreme effect of those he already did not have as much and how the depression made it hard for many people. Great article!!

reply

24/09/2018

1:27 pm

Jorge Martinez

I remember analyzing this photo during my 6th period in my junior year of highschool for US History. Dorothea Lange’s photo has truly survived the tests of time and effectively demonstrates the struggles of the middle and lower class during the Great Depression. I actually did not know the iconic photo was called the “Migrant Mother”, and the title makes a lot of sense.

reply

24/09/2018

1:27 pm

Greyson Addicott

The great depression was a very strange event, to say the least. This article did a great job explaining the power of photography as a whole, and it touched on very specific examples within America’s history. The great depression was a time of suffering, but many things occurred within the time period that would cause much more suffering in the future. The centralization of government and the subsequent enslavement of the States was finally completed with FDR’s horrible policy. FDR’s national bank set prices, but our citizens were still working for wages based upon real, tangible gold. Our States lost the power to fund themselves independent from their “benevolent” federal head in Washington, and all of our businesses lost the power to control their economy and profit. Who could blame them? America’s economic stability depends solely on an unelected, shady board of despots. There was a reason Anddrew Jackson went to war with the banks, and it was certainly not just for fun.

reply

24/09/2018

1:27 pm

Samantha Luckey

Dorothea Lange is known as an iconic photographer that captured the true suffering of the Great Depression. However, it is all too common for the art itself too out-shine the artist. Which of course makes logical sense, because barring some sort extortionary event, the art in most cases will outlive the artist. Therefore, I believe that your article holds great significance. Because, while I hold no doubt that many have seen the photograph of the, “Migrant Mother,” I do doubt their ability to name the context of the piece. Some, in my opinion reduce the importance of the photo, to that of just a suffering mother. When, it more than that. The “Migrant Mother,” captures the significance of the Great Depression, while your article contextualizes the history around the photo.

reply

24/09/2018

1:27 pm

Alyssa Garza

This article has a very powerful message behind it and It’s an amazing story. The title alone hooked me into clicking on this article and it was interesting to see how photos can change how we all see things. Dorothea Lange photos that she takes capture the emotions and everything going on during that time which make her photos specking more than a thousand words.

reply

24/09/2018

1:27 pm

Victoria Rodriguez

This was a treasure trove of information! I do recall seeing this photo plastered all over history books and Great Depression era photos. It is extremely powerful and I feel like it created a new genre of photography. One of which is honest, painful and gives humanity things to think about. The article as a whole, did well expressing the photographers journey as well as the people affected by the Great Depression. It is almost hard to believe how people survived this and even harder to believe how a country developed so greatly out of such hardships.

reply

25/09/2018

1:27 pm

Engelbert Madrid

I decided to read this article because of the title. I’m familiar with the picture demonstrated on the top of the article, but I didn’t have a solid understanding behind it. I know it was based during The Great Depression, but it is important to know why it’s so important for that time period. After I read the entire article, I can say that I agree with the title that images, pictures, or illustrations can be worth more than one thousand words. Visual presentation is the hook of the eye.

reply

25/09/2018

1:27 pm

William Rittenhouse

It’s so cool how pictures are so valuable and are able to used to create a powerful message. In this case, without the use of photos depicting what was really going on, I think people wouldn’t have got the message as fast that people are starving and suffering. Lange seemed like a very caring and loving person. Why else would she of dedicated a lot of her lifes work? To spread the powerful images along to the rest of America so people could understand what was going on.

reply

25/09/2018

1:27 pm

Alexander Manibusan

The great depression was, indeed, a horrific event where people in the U.S, and even around the world, faced a brutal hardship. What was worse was that the U.S government was slow to act, until president Roosevelt came into action. While actions speak louder than words, those pictures that Dorothea Lange captured offered people a spark to show the world that this is what’s happening and it must be changed. Lovely article!

reply

26/09/2018

1:27 pm

Luisa Ortiz

Migrant Mother” is one of my ultimate pictures of U.S History, so when I saw the article’s picture I was completely sure I wanted to read about it. I always say that pictures are the perfect way of keeping history alive, pictures give you memories that you can hold on to it. The article is very well written as I read it felt like I was in the car with Dorothea Lange, excellent job, and great job on the pictures!

reply

26/09/2018

1:27 pm

1 5 6 7

Leave a Reply