StMU Research Scholars

Featuring Scholarly Research, Writing, and Media at St. Mary’s University

September 30, 2018

The Birth of The Enchanted Place

Imagine going back in time to World War II. You’re somewhere in the battle zone staring up at a cloudy gray sky, hoping you would be going home soon. But you didn’t know what home meant as your hands kept squeezing the weapon that was made to save some lives by ending others. This was the world now, covered in darkness and remembered in death. It never felt like it would never end for you and for the millions of others participating in the war. But then you remembered a story your mother read to you when you were a child. You slowly would press your lips together and start to whistle. It was a familiar tune that a yellow bear would blow when he and a little boy walked through the woods together.

The tune you were whistling was made by a man unlike you or I; he was a creator of a story that would be known to children for decades to come. But the 1940s is too far in the future for the beginning of this story. We need to go back to the Great War, where a young hesitate solider named Alan Alexander Milne stood with his countrymen in the trenches along the Western Front. Young Alan Milne was a writer who had been forced into a role he truly never wished play. He hated the idea of war. But fate can be cruel, and from 1914 to 1918, his eyes were bombarded with only death, hopelessness, and darkness.1 War can change how a person sees the world, and that is what it did to Milne. The colors of black and red stained his eyes and would be burned into his mind when he eventually came home. Once Alan did returned to his civilian life, he suffered severely from what they called Shell Shock. Because of those experiences in the trenches, he slowly drifted away from his wife and son. Milne couldn’t get over what he saw and experienced in those trenches. But what was worse was that he didn’t understand how to cope.

Photograph of writer A. A. Milne | September 1922 | Courtesy of Wikimedia Commons
Alan Milne became a writer when he returned from the war, and he enjoyed writing his first comedic play Mr. Pim Passes By.2 Milne was always juggling ideas on what to write, initially leaning towards the detective genre that was then growing in popularity. He eventually published his own detective novel, called The Red House Mystery.3 At the end of the day, however, it would have taken Sherlock Holmes to figure out what Milne was going to publish next, because he jumped from writing poems to plays to novels. It wasn’t until Milne hear from his illustrator and editor (who published his poem “The Dormouse and the Doctor”) that he should look into writing a children’s book.4 It was actually quite ironic, because Milne was not good with children at all, nor did he even like them.5

So, Milne would sit at home and try to make some attempt at his new-found project, but he usually only came up with simple verses that he had some friends read to judge how they felt about them.6 But Milne wasn’t getting anywhere with only having more people suggest more topics to think about. What was he going to write about? A children’s book? Who and what? When and where, and why? Milne was starting to get stumped, but luckily he wasn’t alone anymore. On the floor above him, a child quietly played in the nursery with a toy bear only one year younger than he was.7

One day, as Milne was sitting at his desk, he brought his sharp eyes away from his work, noticing someone that he found himself distant from and who went by the name, Billy Moon. If you asked anyone close to the Milne’s family, they would say that their only son was named Billy Moon, but in fact, he wasn’t.8 His actual name was Christopher Robin Milne. And suddenly, in his father’s mind, an idea was forming. Alan slowly started to observe how Christopher played with his stuffed animals. But more importantly, he observed how the little boy gave them life. He would shout and dance with a smile on his face that would make anyone want to join in too. Christopher would grab his soft yellow teddy bear’s paw and race into the five-hundred-acre woods that surrounded their home. Alan Milne would see his son run with eyes full of belief, so that if you saw what he did, you could watch all the other toys run after him.

Photograph of the true Christopher Robin Milne with his Winnie the Pooh | 1927 | Courtesy of Flickr

At night, Milne started to talk to Christopher about his toys, and how each response he made to his toys made him feel as though they were real, that all the laughs and complaints they made really did happen. One instant, the yellow bear got so angry Milne and Christopher that they found him face first on the floor pouting: “… Pooh was missing from the dinner-table which he always graced. She asked where he was. ‘Behind the ottoman,’ replied his owner coldly. ‘Face downwards. He said he didn’t like When We Were Very Young.’ Pooh’s jealousy was natural. He could never quite catch up with the verses.”9

Soon, father and son started spending a lot of time together. Milne would even join his son into the woods. He saw how Christopher jumped and yelled as if expecting something to yell back, and there were times when it felt like there was a soft gentle voice echoing towards the pair.10 The clock was still ticking for Alan Milne to produce something to publish, and he eventually got away from small verses to writing some short stories of Christopher Robin and his friends. Milne even started to read them to Christopher at the end of the day, jotting down whatever comment Billy or his teddy bear had to offer.11 Alan Milne was not only bonding with his son he barely knew, but he was also, maybe without even realizing, writing away some of the ghosts that followed him back from the war.

What is better for a child? A story that has an end, or a book filled with simple tales whose messages will change as you grow older? Before he could continue to write, there had to be a home for everyone, and why not where all the playing actually took place. Alan Milne based the foundation of Hundred Acre Woods on the forest 500 Acre Woods (Ashdown Forest), but that was not all he kept the same. For the characters he went with his son Christopher Robin (leaving out the last name) and the toys he played with, and eventually other children would as well: Piglet, Kanga, Roo, Tigger, Eeyore, then of course Winnie-The-Pooh. Still, Alan Milne was the creator of this world and he added some of his own characters known to us as Rabbit and Owl.12

It still wasn’t over yet and Alan Milne had a lot of work to do. He continued writing short verses along with reading them to his son to make sure each chapter and each new adventure lived up to the “real” characters’ approval. And he didn’t stop there, Milne went on to have his perspectives in the writing shift from first person to third person, then lastly to second person.13 He wanted the reader truly to feel a part of their private world. After enough stories had been compiled together for a book, he put them in the order he thought best before meeting with Ernest H. Shepard, who would eventually come to illustrate all three books that Milne would publish based on his son. What made Shepard’s work so memorable is that even though he drew them as toys, he made them feel real as he kept the character Christopher Robin looking like Milne’s only son.14 Even when Disney bought Winnie-The-Pooh and created their own version of the characters, Shepard’s work is still symbolizing the realness of childhood.

Original sketch of Christopher nailing on Eeyore’s tail correctly | Courtesy of Flickr

The book was published on October 15, 1926, and it was called Winnie-The-Pooh after the name of the gentle teddy bear that changed so often before the young Christopher Robin Milne decided to settle on the title that would be written in history. England fell in love with the stories, and became obsessed with how there was truthfulness in each word and in every thought muttered on each page. This truthfulness would eventually lead to a variety of complications between Milne and his son, who would develop resentment towards his father for “stealing his childhood.”15 But both men were cast into the shadow of Winnie-The-Pooh because of how much the world needed him. The second decade of the twentieth century was a time of death, and a new war was not far off. Winnie-The-Pooh, Now We Are Six, and The House at Pooh Corner were all people had that reminded them that there used to be a better place, an enchanted place where you walked on the ground and as the leaves would snap under your feet, a little yellow bear would be eating some honey, and hearing the crackling of the leaves would decide to leave some honey for you too, if he didn’t eat all first.

  1. Alan Milne, Autobiography: A. A. Milne (New York: E. P. Dutton & Co., Inc., 1939), 247-248.
  2. Alan Milne, Autobiography: A. A. Milne (New York: E. P. Dutton & Co., Inc., 1939), 247-245.
  3. Alan Milne, Autobiography: A. A. Milne (New York: E. P. Dutton & Co., Inc., 1939), 276.
  4. Alan Milne, Autobiography: A. A. Milne (New York: E. P. Dutton & Co., Inc., 1939), 280-281.
  5. Christopher Milne, The Enchanted Places (New York: E. P. Dutton & Co., Inc., 1974), 36.
  6. Alan Milne, Autobiography: A. A. Milne (New York: E. P. Dutton & Co., Inc., 1939), 278-281.
  7. Christopher Milne, The Enchanted Places (New York: E. P. Dutton & Co., Inc., 1974), 76.
  8. Alan Milne, Autobiography: A. A. Milne (New York: E. P. Dutton & Co., Inc., 1939), 278.
  9. Christopher Milne, The Enchanted Places (New York: E. P. Dutton & Co., Inc., 1974), 63.
  10. Christopher Milne, The Enchanted Places (New York: E. P. Dutton & Co., Inc., 1974), 63.
  11. Alan Milne and Ernest H. Shepard, Winnie-The-Pooh (New York: Dell Publishing Co., Inc., 1926), 160-161.
  12. Christopher Milne, The Enchanted Places (New York: E. P. Dutton & Co., Inc., 1974), 76.
  13. Alan Milne and Ernest H. Shepard, Winnie-The-Pooh (New York: Dell Publishing Co., Inc., 1926), 3-22.
  14. Alan Milne and Ernest H. Shepard, The House At Pooh Corner (New Work: Dell Publishing Co., Inc., 1928), 73-75.
  15. Christopher Milne, The Enchanted Places (New York: E. P. Dutton & Co., Inc., 1974), 166.

Tags from the story

Alan Alexander Milne

Christopher Robin


Recent Comments

Dylan Coons

A great history lesson on what is to most people the most popular character of their early childhood. The article was great at provoking an emotional response out of the reader due to the fantastic wording and the nostalgic feeling one gets due to reminiscing about their days watching the cartoon when they were a child. Good work on this!



8:56 am

Dylan Sanchez

Such a beautiful article. The introduction caught my attention like no other article I have read. It gave me that hopeless feeling. Once the talk of the actual stories of Pooh and how it came to be with the characters came about, it made me happy. This man, who saw evil in the world, changed the world and made it seem beautiful to so many other people. How? fantastic article.



8:56 am

Alexandra Lopez

Reading this article has been very informative and eye-opening because no one would suspect a veteran who disliked children can write about a famous bear who loves honey. When I was younger I had loved Winnie the Pooh because of his soft voice and funny tendencies, but what is most interesting is the idea of this bear was created during a war. With simple lessons on friendship, courage, love, honest, and hope Milne explained these important lessons so effortlessly. (reposted)



8:56 am

Michael Hinojosa

This article was a perfect emotional roller coaster that brought forth a lot of context going on for the creation of “The Enchanted Place” and the history behind everyones favorite bear! I actually didn’t know that Winnie the Pooh was created during the war so it was kind of a huge emotional shock when I found that out, I always thought Winnie the Pooh was a more modern kids story, not one during that time!



8:56 am

Dalton Moy

This was an amazing article. I loved watching Winnie the Pooh when I was growing up. Many children through generations have loved watching him too. I had heard a little about the true story behind Winnie the Pooh, but hadn’t looked too much into it. I am glad to have stumbled upon this article. It was great to read about the true story behind one of my favorite childhood characters.



8:56 am

Cameron Lopez

I love Weenie the Pooh ever since I was a child and the beginning was actually super sad but great nonetheless. I knew Weenie the Pooh was created during the war and it really feels like its been so long ago even though It was not even that long ago. Although I had no idea that the story was inspired by the men that were serving out country.



8:56 am

Diego Terrazas

The introduction really set a paradoxical mood of gory and innocence. It is odd to find out Winnie the Pooh was created during the war and by a veteran at that. It is sad to read that he was diagnosed with shell shock but it was nice that he was able to cope with it somewhat by becoming a writer. I remember learning that Winnie the pooh had some depressing moments and subliminal underlying messages perhaps they originated from Milne.



8:56 am

Vania Gonzalez

The article is very beautiful I did not know how the greatest story and character of probably everyone’s child hood was inspired by the war. It’s a really sweet article and it’s based on partly true things which is what makes people connect to things when they can feel some realness in the book. Also I can’t believe this book was written in parts and almost did not make it because it was hard for Milne write a children’s book.



8:56 am

Addie Piatz

Winnie the Pooh is the definition of my childhood. I grew up with all the characters in the stories. I loved this article and the story behind Winnie the Pooh in general. I specifically love how the story’s main purpose was to help with the war and the people fighting in it. It did however, make me a little upset that hit altered their father-sone relationship.



8:56 am

Azucena Cuevas

This was such an amazing article and the introduction was really well written. I had only heard briefly about the story of Winnie the Pooh and how he was created during the war. However, this article is more informative and it uses great diction that tags at the emotions of the reader. It’s amazing that at such a hard time, he created a beautiful story.



8:56 am

1 2 3

Leave a Reply