StMU Research Scholars

Featuring Scholarly Research, Writing, and Media at St. Mary’s University

October 7, 2021

The Golden Age of Piracy: The Real Pirates of The Caribbean

The Caribbean Islands, 1715: Blood on the water. The black flag flies proudly as pirates plunder and pillage the high seas seemingly without consequence, bringing world empires to their knees. Adventurers and swashbucklers from all over the world flock to the islands eager to pursue their fortunes. Among these maritime raiders came three of the most notorious pirates to ever sail the seven seas: the brutish Charles Vane, the wild and clever “Calico” Jack Rackham, and the terror of the Caribbean himself, Edward Thatch, known endearingly among his fellow plunderers as Blackbeard. What these men desire most is fortune and glory…but their unquenchable thirst for gold and silver would eventually prove to be their downfall. 

To understand the origins of our troublesome trio of pirates, our story will begin following the events of the Spanish War of the Succession. England and Spain had just emerged from a particularly disastrous conflict, in which colonial land was conquered, surrendered, conquered, and surrendered again in an endless cycle of destruction.1 During the war, a Spanish fleet seized the British Caribbean island of Nassau, hoping to teach the British a firm lesson in violence. In the year 1703, in a series of catastrophic events, the Spaniards plundered the island of its riches, slaughtered its inhabitants, and razed it to the ground. The once tropical paradise had been reduced to a mere pile of ash, left utterly abandoned of its life and settlers. Seeing that preserving Nassau as a colonial province was a lost cause, England withdrew all presence from New Providence Island and left it to rot as a backwater, shoddy outpost of disease and filth.2

Years passed, and Nassau remained empty. With the signing of the Peace of Utrecht between Britain and Spain in 1713, English privateers found themselves unemployed; many decided to abandon their careers and resort to piracy.3 Following the Spanish war, rumors of an unoccupied island, free of British control, started to spread all across the Caribbean. Around 1713, Captain Benjamin Hornigold, a veteran of the Spanish War himself, settled on the island with a ragtag band of former privateers. With him was a young Edward Thatch, whom Hornigold would take as an apprentice and introduce to a life of piracy.4 Drunkards, tradesmen, merchants, and pirates alike began to flock to Nassau; its utopian appeal attracted other famed seafaring marauders, such as the wealthy planter-turned-pirate Stede Bonnet, the female pirates Anne Bonny and Mary Reade, and Sam Bellamy, among others. Among the new wave of arrivals between 1716 and 1717 was an ambitious English captain, Charles Vane, and his cunning first mate, Jack Rackham.5 Many other pirates continued to discover a safe haven on Nassau; however, none stood out more than the terrifying trio themselves. Combined with the mentorship of Benjamin Hornigold, the brutality of Vane and Blackbeard, and the cleverness of Rackham, the pirates of Nassau came together and declared war: not only on England, but on all civilization.

As the number of pirates on Nassau increased, it was time to get busy. At the suggestion of Captain Hornigold and Blackbeard, the pirates agreed to fortify Nassau’s old British defenses to prevent against incursions by fellow pirates and the English Crown alike. The leading council of pirates, consisting of Hornigold, Blackbeard, Rackham, and Vane, established a makeshift, yet somewhat efficient, Republic. Though there seems to be a lack of evidence to suggest that they had a clear set of laws, their word was respected all throughout New Providence Island.6

Charles Vane, as portrayed by actor Zach McGowan on Black Sails; the unpredictable one of the bunch | Courtesy of Pinterest

Blackbeard, Vane, and Rackham did most of the dirty work when it came to plundering. Together, they began to seize prizes on the high seas, capturing merchant ships and sinking British vessels left and right. With hulls full of plunder and booty, Blackbeard and Vane decided to take it a step further, embarking beyond Nassau’s waters—and they began to terrorize the Atlantic coast. With his trusty brig The Ranger, and Jack Rackham as his second, Charles Vane went on a rampage, plundering the waters spanning from the Caribbean to as far north as the New York coast. He was known for his cruelty towards his captives, punishing and torturing them in sadistic methods. One of Vane’s notable prizes was a Bermudan merchant vessel, known as the Diamond, which was traversing the waters surrounding the Bahamas at the time of its capture. Vane’s crew overcame the ship swiftly, and with exceptional brutality. In a testimony given to the governor of Bermuda, one survivor alleged that Vane had tortured him with a cutlass, then hung him. Furthermore, the captain of another Bermudan vessel, the William and Martha, attested that Vane had humiliated the merchant crew with severe beatings and torture methods, including burning them with lit matches. Vane was fond of a particular form of torture and execution known as keelhauling, in which the victim was tied up with a rope, thrown overboard, and dragged from one side of the ship to the other. The victim would be forced to endure an unimaginable amount of pain, often to the point of bleeding out, in which the barnacles attached to the ship’s hull would inflict punishing lacerations to their bare skin.7

Contrary to the attitudes of his captain, Rackham was the quietest of the trio, preferring the art of plotting and planning from the shadows rather than cruelty and brute force. As the Ranger’s first mate and quartermaster, he was charged with managing the crew and keeping order aboard at all times. He followed Vane on every heist, lending a calming ear to his captain when he could. Rackham and Vane had a love-hate relationship; although the two often disagreed, together, they were an unstoppable force of pirate might. Rackham had the brains, and Vane had the brawn. Besides being incredibly cunning, Rackham was also a womanizer; between the years 1718 and 1719, Rackham recruited a female pirate, Anne Bonny, to the crew. The couple became lovers, and for the rest of Rackham’s pirating career, they would never leave each other’s side. Much to the annoyance of Charles Vane, Jack’s charisma, cleverness, and romantic nature found favor among the crew, who were growing increasingly weary of the captain’s cruel demeanor. Rackham is credited with pioneering the design of the Jolly Roger, the black flag emblazoned with a skull and crossed swords that signaled impending death upon all who saw it.8

The most recognizable pirate symbol of them all, the Jolly Roger; pioneered by Jack Rackham | Courtesy of Wikipedia

In 1717, Blackbeard’s campaign extended its terrifying reach from the waters of Chesapeake Bay to Philadelphia and the upper eastern coast, as he traveled back and forth between northern and Caribbean waters. Blackbeard’s plundering would not have been possible without his prized frigate, the Queen Anne’s Revenge. Formerly a French slave ship known as La Concorde, she boasted a massive broadside of French and English cannons, and was known for her impressive sailing speed. Just on his Atlantic campaign alone, Blackbeard captured fifteen ships within a span of a few weeks, which was a great accomplishment for even the most skilled pirates. Blackbeard’s notoriety allowed him to amass a small pirate fleet, which included Stede Bonnet and his own brig, the Revenge.9 Vessel after vessel fell victim to Blackbeard and his cohorts, all the while the elusive captain evaded capture by the Royal Navy. Blackbeard’s greatest and most daring feat, however, was the infamous blockade of Charleston, in which he and his fleet laid siege to the Charleston harbor for six days, sinking or capturing any merchant vessels that dared to pass by. Blackbeard held his unfortunate prey of captured crewmen for ransom, vowing not to end his blockade until Charleston agreed to pay him in medicines to treat syphilis. Eyewitness testimony from his captives attested that Blackbeard oftentimes did not plunder for resources, but simply just to delight in destruction—in which he leveled entire coastal settlements and sank or burned merchant ships without cause. Accounts within A General History Of The Pirates allege that Blackbeard was a fearsome fighter, armed with a bandolier of flintlock pistols; apparently, Blackbeard would also tie lit fuses to the bottom of his captain’s hat to make him appear more devilish in battle.10

A 1725 woodcut of Calico Jack from “A General History Of The Pirates” by Charles Johnson | Courtesy of Wikipedia

Despite the temporary success of the pirates, a new arrival had thrown Nassau into despair. While Blackbeard was taking a temporary vacation from piracy off the North Carolina coast, Vane returned to Nassau to flaunt his prizes. Little did he know, however, that Nassau was about to be changed forever. Observing that the piracy problem in the Caribbean and the Atlantic coast was out of control, King George I appointed Woodes Rogers as governor of New Providence Island. The King gave the pirates an ultimatum: to take a royal pardon and live their lives as penniless, but free men, or to die as pirates either by the sword or by the noose. By the year 1718, Rogers had arrived to Nassau with an English fleet, promises of civilization, and a full list of pardons. Captain Hornigold, the once proud mentor of pirates far and wide, took the pardon and agreed to hunt down his former associates.11 Jack Rackham, in an effort to secure his own life and that of his swashbuckling lover, Anne Bonny, agreed to the pardon. Vane and Blackbeard, however, were not amused by the governor’s antics. Vane openly refused the pardon, and in an incredible display of pirate heroism, launched a fireship into the governor’s blockade, and ordered the Ranger to fire its cannons on Rogers’ flagship.12 In the confusion, Vane successfully escaped Nassau; and Blackbeard continued his pirate rampage across the Atlantic.

Blackbeard, as portrayed by actor Ian McShane in Pirates Of The Caribbean: On Stranger Tides | Courtesy of Pinterest

The die had been cast; the pirates had played their cards, and it was up to Governor Rogers to make the next move. Rogers was determined to end the scourge of piracy once and for all, and he enlisted the help of eager pirate hunters from all across the British Empire. Blackbeard and Vane had made no friends across the high seas during their years of raiding and plundering; indeed, there was no shortage of those who wanted to see their destructive campaigns come to a swift end. At some point in 1718, Vane was deposed as captain of the Ranger. His cruel methods were not appreciated by his crew, who viewed him as a greedy and tyrannical leader. The crew conducted a mutiny and voted in Rackham as captain. As a result, Vane was marooned on a desert island off the coast of Honduras, where he eventually found refuge on a passing merchant vessel. Unfortunately, the ship’s captain recognized Vane, and turned him over to British authorities. In 1720, he was tried in Port Royal, Jamaica, and found guilty of piracy. Vane was executed the following year.13

Rackham eventually abandoned the governor’s pardon and returned to piracy. He proved to be an efficient leader, but his captaincy was short lived. In 1720, Rackham was captured by pirate hunters and imprisoned in Port Royal. He pleaded his innocence on all four counts of piracy, but his testimony proved futile. Rackham ultimately suffered the same fate as Charles Vane—he too was executed, and his body was hung to rot in a gibbet outside of Port Royal’s harbor.14 Blackbeard fell in battle during a naval skirmish with British troops off the mainland of Ocracoke. In a surprise attack, he was overcome by the combined forces of British Lieutenants Alexander Spotswood and Robert Maynard. Although his crew managed to put up a great fight and killed a significant amount of British soldiers, the fearsome captain met his end aboard the enemy’s ship. Blackbeard’s body was dumped into the sea, and his head was allegedly granted as a trophy to Spotswood.15

With the death of the last great Caribbean pirates, the Golden Age of Piracy had come to a close. Small pockets of pirates still remained throughout the Bahamas, but none ever rose to the infamy of Nassau’s formidable trio of marauders. In the end, civilization proved to be stronger than the pirates; under the careful eye of Governor Rogers, the once wild and free island was tamed, finally welcomed once again with open arms into the embrace of the British Empire. The pirate’s life slowly drifted away, into the annals of history; it was now nothing more than a fantasy, a long lost dream of aspiring adventurers and daredevils. The Golden Age of Piracy may have come to an end, but it remained forever burnt into the minds of those who experienced it. 

  1. James A Ogilvy, “War of the Spanish Succession, The Canadian Encyclopedia,” The Canadian Encyclopedia, accessed October 1, 2021, https://www.thecanadianencyclopedia.ca/en/article/war-of-the-spanish-succession.
  2. Aaron Higgins, “The Republic of Pirates,” Nassau in the Atlantic World (blog), accessed September 27, 2021, http://aaronhiggins.blogs.wm.edu/the-republic-of-pirates/.
  3. Toby Arguello, “Nassau’s Pirates: Revealing the Sordid History of the Bahamian Port City,” Explore the Archive (website), July 15, 2020, https://explorethearchive.com/nassau-pirates-history.
  4. The Legends of History, Benjamin Hornigold: The Man Who Trained Blackbeard (Pirate History Explained), 2018, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GxJep2rzo3Y.
  5. Mark Cartwright, “Charles Vane,” World History Encyclopedia, accessed September 27, 2021, https://www.worldhistory.org/Charles_Vane/.
  6. Aaron Higgins, “The Republic of Pirates,” Nassau in the Atlantic World (blog), accessed September 27, 2021, http://aaronhiggins.blogs.wm.edu/the-republic-of-pirates/.
  7. Mark Cartwright, “Charles Vane,” World History Encyclopedia, accessed September 27, 2021, https://www.worldhistory.org/Charles_Vane/.
  8. Mark Cartwright, “Calico Jack,” World History Encyclopedia, accessed September 27, 2021, https://www.worldhistory.org/Calico_Jack/.
  9. Toby Arguello, “Nassau’s Pirates: Revealing the Sordid History of the Bahamian Port City,” Explore the Archive (website), July 15, 2020, https://explorethearchive.com/nassau-pirates-history.
  10. Colin Woodard, “The Last Days of Blackbeard,” The Smithsonian (website), accessed September 27, 2021, https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/last-days-blackbeard-180949440/.
  11. Aaron Higgins, “The Republic of Pirates,” Nassau in the Atlantic World (blog), accessed September 27, 2021, http://aaronhiggins.blogs.wm.edu/the-republic-of-pirates/.
  12. Mark Cartwright, “Charles Vane,” World History Encyclopedia, accessed September 27, 2021, https://www.worldhistory.org/Charles_Vane/.
  13. Colin Woodard, “The Last Days of Blackbeard,” The Smithsonian Magazine (website), accessed September 27, 2021, https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/last-days-blackbeard-180949440/.
  14. Mark Cartwright, “Calico Jack,” World History Encyclopedia, accessed September 27, 2021, https://www.worldhistory.org/Calico_Jack/.
  15. Colin Woodard, “The Last Days of Blackbeard,” The Smithsonian Magazine (website), accessed September 27, 2021, https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/last-days-blackbeard-180949440/.

Tags from the story

Bahamas

Blackbeard

Caribbean

Charles Vane

Edward Thatch

England

Jack Rackham

Elliot Avigael

I am double majoring in History and Theology at St. Mary’s University. I am absolutely fascinated by and enjoy studying the lives of history’s most cunning military leaders, including Attila the Hun, Genghis Khan, Vlad Tepes, and many others. My passions include writing music, electric guitar, studying Talmud, and reading history.

Author Portfolio Page

Recent Comments

Noelia Torres Guillen

Before I read this article all the information I knew about pirates was through the movies “Pirates of the Caribbean” Reading about the golden age of piracy and the three most famous Pirates made me learn more about European history. I learned more about the characteristics and traits of pirates through this article. I liked how different the trio were. Like vane being ruthless, Rackham being clever, and being successful and well respected like blackbeard. It makes it more easier to team up. This was an informative and kept me hooked and wanting to learn more!

reply

22/01/2023

9:36 am

Martina Flores Guillen

Growing up, the name of the notorious pirate blackboard was the only one that ever stood out to me or that I mainly remember hearing of in fable stories or fantasy movies. Though when reading the article, I was impressed by how many real pirates were known of within historical concepts, the imprint that various meal and some female pirates made alongside historical events is impressive. Pointing out the brutal manner that pirates had when carrying out most of their deals with one another and how each went to extended measures to obtain some price along with a supposed title is a pretty accurate description of what a private life was.

reply

22/01/2023

9:36 am

Phylisha Liscano

Hello, Elliot I first wanted to congratulate you on winning an award. I found this article to be really intriguing, and I enjoyed the chance to read it. I had little to no prior understanding of the age of piracy before reading this, but it’s obvious that you did extensive research to write this article. The article itself is really informative, and I definitely learned more about pirates and their exciting lives as a result. It’s crazy to imagine that in the past, pirates had practically unrestricted access to the Caribbean and the East Coast of America. In this really well-written article, you truly take all that information and make it clear and simple to read.

reply

22/01/2023

9:36 am

Azeneth Lozano

It’s a wild thought to think about pirates once taking over an abandoned British island and becoming a strong force by stealing fortunes. The article gave an impressive amount of information about the origination of piracy and the infamous trio, Vane, Calico, and Blackbeard. In addition to the informative topic, the article was formatted wonderfully and captured my attention from the first paragraph. Congratulations on your well-deserved award!

reply

22/01/2023

9:36 am

Christopher Morales

For starters, the setup from the very first sentence really caught my attention. You recognized and really showed the different perspectives surrounding the trio being a hero or villain. I noticed how you described not only today’s perspective that views his actions of boat dragging or his tyrant behavior, but also the perspective of the people of that time that could see the trio itself as rebels. You also emphasize the people that saw them as unfair thieves, including those in which were on the ships they would seize and the crew they managed. All these painted the picture you were creating very well. You are very deserving of your award.

reply

22/01/2023

9:36 am

Marie Peterson

This article was a really good look into the golden age of piracy and the ways of pirates during this time. The modern idea of pirates in media is often rooted in fiction so it was interesting to see the truths and lies. As well, I found it interesting how they found community and order in their chaos. Great job!

reply

22/01/2023

9:36 am

Donald Glasen

I always found the history of piracy to be an interesting one. It’s always interesting finding parts of histories that are always talked about but never really looked into. I also find it interesting how short the golden age was in the span of human history. Very interesting to see how important pirates were to human history.

reply

22/01/2023

9:36 am

Vincent Villanueva

I really enjoyed the Golden Age of Piracy article because the story of pirates has always been something I enjoyed as a younger kid. This really had me hooked from the start, with the story line and I never would think that pirates had played a huge part in history. I did not know that the Golden Age of the Piracy was even real and that was truly amazing. Wonderful article.

reply

22/01/2023

9:36 am

Ana Diaz

Congratulations on your award, it is well deserved! The topic of pirates is so interesting. With all the media about them like the popular Pirates of the Caribbean series it’s tough to think of them as something other than a fantasy story. I like how you detailed the character and personalities of Vane, Rackham, and Blackbeard. It was interesting to read how different they could be with Rackham being more personable and suave, compared to the stereotypical cruel swashbuckling pirate. Good work!

reply

22/01/2023

9:36 am

Jose Maria Gallegos Cebreros

First, congratulations on writing a great article! My only knowledge about pirates before treading this article was what you see in movies. Some of them made me thing that they were very proud of themselves and selfish and that they would never team up to achieve something, but you prove me wrong! The images that you used pair really well with the information in the article, it helped me picture what was going on during that time in my head.

reply

23/01/2023

9:36 am

1 2 3

Leave a Reply