StMU Research Scholars

Featuring Scholarly Research, Writing, and Media at St. Mary’s University

November 16, 2016

Pain and Beauty Standards: Chinese Foot Binding

Winner of the Fall 2016 StMU History Media Award for

Best Use of Scholarship

Best Article in the Category of “World History”

Best Use of Primary Sources

 

When I knew I couldn’t suffer another moment of pain and tears fell on my bloody bindings, my mother spoke softly into my ear, encouraging me to go one more hour, one more day, one more week, reminding me of the rewards I would have if I carried on a little longer. In this way, she taught me how to endure—not just the physical trials of footbinding or childbearing, but the more torturous pain of the heart, mind, and soul.1

 

More often than necessary, women are consumed with the idea of infatuation. Every culture has its own form of standards that pertain to women and what constitutes beauty. Although the world is slightly more accepting now, women used to go to extreme lengths to achieve an image that would be deemed attractive. In the Chinese culture, foot binding was that well-known beauty expectation for centuries. What started off as a celebrity fad, turned into a way of determining social status and eventually an all-around beauty expectation. 2 The objective of foot binding was for women to have the smallest foot possible, starting at very young ages. Not only was this a painful process for girls as young as five years, but it also promoted the idea that women must mutilate their bodies to become appealing to men. At some point in time, women began to just accept that this was something that was supposed to be done in order to be attractive. Often referred to as “lotus boats” or “golden lotuses,” bound feet started as a fad for the famous, and slowly made its way to becoming the social norm.3

Some women continued to bind their feet, even after laws were enforced against it.
Some women continued to bind their feet, even after laws were passed prohibiting it | Courtesy of Smithsonian.com

This practice began around the tenth century with women in the entertainment business. These women were adored for their tiny arched feet and were seen by men to be much more attractive than middle class women with average feet. As these dancers were gaining an audience, the idea of “lotus feet” was becoming familiar. Not long after these performers expressed their “beauty,” foot binding became a norm for women who wanted to fit in and even for those who had a desire to find a husband.4 This painful process consisted of the breaking of young girl’s toes to form the desired triangular shape. Then the arch of the foot would be bent horizontally from the toes all the way to the heel. As if this was not painful enough, the girls were forced to walk on their feet to intensify the arch, breaking the foot even more. After all of this, the foot would be wrapped to maintain the shape of it as well as prevent any sort of deviation.5

A bound foot, unwrapped from its bandages.
A bound foot, unwrapped from its bandages | Courtesy of the University of Virginia Historical Collections at the Claude Moore Health Sciences Library

Although this practice was around for centuries, it was only a matter of time before someone realized how inhumane and cruel it really was. Thankfully, many people began to protest against foot binding, forming “anti-foot binding organizations” to raise awareness on the inhumanity of binding women’s feet. By the 1950’s, laws were passed, allowing women to unbind their feet. Although hesitant at first, the trend slowly declined. Many women protested to unbinding their feet, due to the fact that it had been a social norm a thousand years. However, the movement against foot binding continued and eventually the last of the factories that make the tiny shoes were shut down, disabling the women from continuing the custom. Today, foot binding is no longer practiced and the only women who continue to maintain the tiny feet are those elder women who refuse to let go of the past.6

  1. Lisa See, Snow Flower and the Secret Fan (New York: Random House Publishers, 2005), 3-4.
  2. Yaodong Gu et al., “Foot Loading Characteristics of Chinese Bound Feet Women: A Comparative Analysis,” PLoS ONE 10, no. 4 (April 2015): 1–9, doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0121695.
  3.  Yu-ning Li, Chinese Women Through Chinese Eyes (New York: Routledge, 2015), 125-127.
  4. Women in the Middle Ages: An Encyclopedia, 2004, s.v. “Footbinding (Late 10th Century-early 20th Century),” by Patricia Buckley Ebrey.
  5. Amanda Foreman, “Why Footbinding Persisted in China for a Millennium,” Smithsonian, accessed November 8, 2016, http://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/why-footbinding-persisted-china-millennium-180953971/.
  6. “Women with Bound Feet in China,” Reshaping the Body: Clothing & Cultural Practice, accessed November 8, 2016, http://exhibits.hsl.virginia.edu/clothes/lady_bound/.

Tags from the story

Beauty

Chinese Culture

Chinese Footbinding

Recent Comments

Esperanza Mauricio

I love to read about Asia culture and their standards which is why I have read little on this subject. Learning more is always wonderful but the beauty standard of foot binding is a little extreme for my liking. Another Asia beauty standard was the obi belt and drape in Japan which could be quite heavy. Unlike how foot binding promotes changing one’s physical attributes. This was a wonderful article to read.

reply

21/11/2016

8:15 am

Alyssa Santos

Great article! This practice has always fascinated and saddened me. It’s amazing how powerful culture can be in reinforcing unhealthy beauty standards for women. Foot binding seems so bizarre and extreme to us now, but it makes me think about popular beauty practices that are normalized today such as waist trainers and even photoshopped images we see in advertising and social media that portray unachievable ideals. Throughout history, it appears, culture has created wild constructs that not only define beauty, but define a woman’s worth by her beauty.

reply

21/11/2016

8:15 am

Edward Enriquez

Very interesting read!!! I had heard about this practice but was not at all familiar with what it actually entailed, nor could I have ever imagined the pain that was endured by these women. It is also crazy to think that some women, even in this day and age, continue to practice this custom.

reply

21/11/2016

8:15 am

Sam Allard

It’s crazy how celebrities and popular people in different cultures can persuade people cultural trends, especially something other this magnitude. I don’t agree that women should need to change to be able to be accepted and they are all perfect in their own ways. Great article!!

reply

21/11/2016

8:15 am

Madeline

I really enjoy the information provided on foot binding. I found the article very interesting.

reply

21/11/2016

8:15 am

Christi Balderas

I just came across this by chance, & had no prior knowledge as to what foot binding was. I’ve heard the term but never really KNEW. After reading your article, I’m much more interested in this as it is so so fascinating! Way to captivate and intrigue the readers in the introduction to the article. Such good and enriching information, also. Great work!

reply

21/11/2016

8:15 am

Corina Garcia

What a great read! I am astonished at how this horrendous “trend” became a social norm. Love the added detail in the article. Detailed yet straightforward and to the point.

reply

22/11/2016

8:15 am

Amanda Cantu

Great Article! Its crazy how people are willing to do dangerous things to be seen as beautiful. Even today with that cup challenge to make your lips bigger, people don’t see how bad and unhealthy it is. I feel so sorry for those women who endured that pain to feel beautiful when everyone is already beautiful. I guess this is where the line beauty is pain comes from. Honestly if thats what it took to be beautiful count me out, its not worth the pain. Keep up the good work!

reply

22/11/2016

8:15 am

Christopher Repka

This is a very interesting article on a cultural beauty standard of the Chinese. While these body altercations are very shocking to most folks, it is also true that there are some strange and peculiar beauty standards held within American culture today. It is interesting to note that many of these beauty altercations occur predominantly within the upper-class. The extreme measures that are often taken to achieve these beauty standards (which aren’t actually that standard) are often quite shocking from an outsider’s perspective.

reply

30/11/2016

8:15 am

Aaron Jaramillo

Great article. It just amazing me how something that started out as a celebrity fad became a society norm and a symbol of beauty. It is sad that if we look at society today, many of today’s females are still looking at celebrities, although maybe to not such inhumane extremes, to set the standards of beauty. As a male, it amazes me the lengths that women think they need to go through to feel they are beautiful. I fully believe that every woman is beautiful in their own way and should not be looking at celebrities to determine what beauty is.

reply

05/12/2016

8:15 am

1 7 8 9 10

Leave a Reply