StMU Research Scholars

Featuring Scholarly Research, Writing, and Media at St. Mary’s University

April 5, 2017

The Sinking of the First USS Maine: 1898

In the New York Navy Yard, on October 17, 1888, many American ship builders began building a 6,682 ton battleship soon to be named the USS Maine. This second-class battleship sported four 10 inch and six 6 inch cannons, and 15 pound guns with four 14 inch torpedo tubes when she was launched from the navy yard a year later in November 1889. She was commissioned on September 17, 1895, her was Captain Arent S. Crowninshield, and she crewed 350 men; a few months after her commissioning, she was on her way to her first and final voyage, which was a peace keeping mission to Cuba.1

The USS Maine near Havana | Courtesy of the Naval Historic Center

In January of 1898, the USS Maine steamed from the Florida Keys to Havana Cuba. A Cuban fight for independence from Spain was underway, and with American citizens in Cuba caught in the cross-fire, the presence of an American battleship there would demonstrate US concerns to Spain about those American citizens. The ship was there in what the United Stated called a “friendly act,” though there wasn’t many friendly feeling from the Spanish authorities toward the battleship being in their harbor. No actions against the ship were taken. But at 9:40 P.M. on 15 February, that all changed. Two explosions rocked the ship as it threw pieces of the Maine two-hundred feet in the air as it illuminated the whole harbor. The first explosion was a small dull roar that was followed by a much more powerful second explosion. The explosion was larger due to the forward magazines going off in the fire. The forward half of the ship was reduced to a mass of twisted steel; the aft section slowly sank, leaving two officers and 258 members of the crew dead in the aftermath of the destruction.2

The exploding of the USS Manie | Courtesy of Fouquet on Wikimedia Commons

Upon hearing what happened to the USS Maine, both the Spanish and American Governments sent their own investigators to the wreck to determine what happened to the ship. Both investigators came up with completely different conclusions as to the cause of the explosions. The Spanish said that the cause was an internal explosion in the coal bunker, while the American investigator said it was an external explosion that set off the forward magazine after the first explosion. While the investigators were working on the causes, the remaining survivors were rushed to hospitals on a ward steamer and a Spanish cruiser. Eight of those survivors subsequently died. Once news of the Maine’s explosion and the deaths of American sailors reached the States, many Americans believed that the explosion was due an external explosion caused by a shady individual, and they demanded an armed intervention against the Spanish. Though this wasn’t the cause of the Spanish-American War, it was certainly a catalyst for starting it.3

The hulk of the USS Maine | Courtesy of the Naval Historic Center

The wreck of the Maine stayed in Havana’s harbor for years, until 1911, when the American Government sent a group of Army engineers to raise the wreck. There they found that the aft section was the only intact part of the ship, so they raised it and floated it out to sea. Then, on the 16th of March, 1912, the Maine was given her minute gun salute as she sank with her flag flowing proudly one last time. Remains of the crew found with her were subsequently laid to rest as well in Arlington cemetery. Before she was sunk, officials performed one last set of investigations. They found evidence that pointed to a faulty boiler as the possible cause of the explosion, but they still lacked conclusive evidence to support the theory, so the cause of the explosion is still undetermined and we may never know for sure what caused the Maine to explode.4

  1.  The Dictionary of American Naval Fighting Ships, 2009, s.v. “USS Maine,” by Naval Historic Center.
  2. Dictionary of American History, 2003, s.v. “Maine, Sinking of the Maine.”
  3.  The Dictionary of American Naval Fighting Ships, 2009, s.v. “USS Maine,” by Naval Historic Center.
  4. Dictionary of American History, 2003, s.v. “Sinking of The Maine,” by Walter B. Norris.

Tags from the story

USS Maine

Recent Comments

Zaraly Frasquillo

Very interesting article, but I did have a bit of a problem reading in some parts of the essay. For example, the last sentence on the first paragraph, I believe you meant to say that her captain was… I understood perfectly but it was hard to read a bit. Other than that little issue I had, I definitely loved learning about the USS Maine, mainly because it is a topic that we might have learned in History but we did not really put much attention to it. Great job!

reply

05/04/2017

7:45 am

Marissa Gonzalez

I find it quite unusual how the cause for the explosion is still not determined until this day. It is also unfortunate how so many people died because of this, even some of those that were taken away after the explosion. One question that I do have is what evidence is missing or what needs to be known in order to gain more information regarding the cause of the explosions since there is another theory that it may have been a person that caused it. I learned a lot about the USS Maine that I was not aware of before. Good job!

reply

06/04/2017

7:45 am

Nahim Rancharan

This was a very well written article. I liked how this article effectively highlighted the mystery of the USS Maine explosion in the Havana Harbor. Although it was an unfortunate even in American History, it is hard to think that there was no conclusion to the investigation of the primary causes of the explosion of the ship. Was it a faulty error or was it a planned explosion? Most importantly, it was great that the article provided the other side of this unfortunate event, which is the second sinking of the USS Maine. It was a great and patriotic event that helped to remedy and honor the many Americans affected by this tragic event in history. Great Article!

reply

06/04/2017

7:45 am

Aimee Trevino

Wow, really interesting article! I had heard of the infamous USS Maine, but I honestly never knew that it was headed to Havana, Cuba, and the whole reasoning behind it. It is insane to see that the two different investigators covering this case had completely different stories as to what the cause may have been. I think it would be really interesting to have today’s researchers find a cause, and compare it. Overall, really interesting topic!

reply

06/04/2017

7:45 am

Lianna Ybarra

I had never heard about the sinking of the first USS Maine! It’s sad how it was caused by an internal factor such as the boiler, but I can see how the people on the ship would think of it as someone else’s fault. You did a great job of opening up the article with background information and a lot of facts about the ship. You did a great job catching the reader up if they hadn’t heard about this before.

reply

07/04/2017

7:45 am

Jennifer Pogue

This is a very interesting article. It is one of those moments in history that sometimes is forgotten and we don’t learn about it. I find the two different investigators sides almost amusing. I feel if something like this were to happen today, our experts could quickly find the fault. But hopefully before it came to that, the error would be caught during testing! It is frightening how much trust we put into these machines that are made by humans.

reply

07/04/2017

7:45 am

Alexis Soto

Aside from some confusing word choices this was an informative article. It was able to explain the mysterious nature of the sinking of the US Maine. It also was able to demonstrate the aftermath of the sinking of the ship. I had no idea their was two different investigations that had to different causes to explain the incident. Overall I enjoyed this article.

reply

07/04/2017

7:45 am

Nelson Smithwick

“Remember the Maine” was always one of the phrases that i connected to the Spanish american war, however i never knew that its actual connection to the war itself was so tenuous. The sinking of the ship was definitely tragic however it is probably worse that this accident was blamed on the Spanish and help start the Spanish american war, even if it wasn’t the only cause of that conflict.

reply

07/04/2017

7:45 am

Aidan

Its “Remember the Maine to hell with Spain”

reply

20/02/2019

7:45 am

Hayden Hollinger

I was drawn to this article straight away and I was not disappointed. I thought this was an interesting article that did a good job of documenting the sinking of the first USS Maine, all the way back in 1898. I thought the images used helped the article a lot in giving a visual representation of what happened and to help the reader get a good picture of how bad the sinking really was.

reply

07/04/2017

7:45 am

Natalia Zuniga

Interesting article!I can tell you took a lot of time and did a lot of research for this article! I never really knew much about the first USS Maine, so it was great to get to know this part of history. The old photo of the USS Maine was great and caught my attention, as well as your photos of the USS Maine was great. Overall great article!

reply

07/04/2017

7:45 am

1 2

Leave a Reply